Pre-Game Talk: Lets Light This Candle. Edmonton v Winnipeg, Wednesday 8 PM.

McFlyingV

Registered User
Feb 22, 2013
23,743
15,683
Edmonton, Alberta
These guys don't get it.

Holloway flat out told Andy Strickland the offer was 3.1 over three years. So about a Mil a year over a three year term lol. That was enough to piss him off because it wasn't a serious offer with that term.

Yet the GM's here try to compare it to the Nick Robertson signing which was 900k for ONE year. Laughable.

Then they say, well no way was Holloway worth the offer sheet, failing to use any logic or understanding how they got there.
When you look at the contract Kent Johnson signed the Oilers offer doesn't look that far off. Maybe by 2-300k per year at most.
 

Oilhawks

Over Old Hills
Nov 24, 2011
28,277
51,045
The constant 180s people here are doing over these two should be studied in psychology schools.

Broberg went from a guy people would have been happy to get a 2nd for in a throw away deal all the way to some sort of key player on the basis of about 3 good games on the bottom pair in the playoffs.

Holloway is a band aid that played half a season (again), produced all of about Jack shit in the 38 games he did play, and had about 50/50 support at best to be in the opening playoff lineup. Then by virtue of losing him all of a sudden we’re dumb for not voluntarily overpaying him in advance.

Any deal for these two above about $1.5M AAV each would have been met with resounding screams from here, and justifiably so. Only when we lost them was it all of a sudden dumb that we didn’t just voluntarily overpay them before.

Captain hindsight and goal post moving at its absolute worst.

The worst part is that, with regards to the bolded, it would be coming from a lot of the same posters, that just bitch and moan about absolutely anything the team does.

It's a shame we don't live in alternate reality where the Oilers won game 7 and these same posters would whine about something like "that's great and all, but they almost got swept, need to do it better next time"
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 5 Mins 4 Ftg

T-Funk

Registered User
Oct 15, 2006
14,912
5,720
no-question-about-it-ready-to-get-hurt-again.gif
 

McFlash97

Registered User
Oct 10, 2017
7,549
6,651
Did we lowball him?

Nick Robertson who had much better stats last year signed for like 900k.

Having to talk in capitals like that doesn’t help you get your point across by the way, just makes people laugh at you.
The fact your comparing Nick Robertson to a Oiler drafted and developed pick, who played superb in the playoffs, was an absolute horse on the forecheck and gained valuable playoff experience. Also gelling with the guys in the room. He was lowballed by this organization, yet we resign a 40 year old skeleton, then go try to replace Holloway with an enigmatic outcasted Russian from Vancouver of all places, who nearly makes what Holloway was asking for initially is quite funny.

Some Oiler fans just keep running in circles without realizing they are in one...
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad