Legitimate All-Star Lineups

[zeke]

Malkin - Crosby - Stamkos
Datsyuk - Giroux - Voracek
Nash - Tavares - Kessel
Zetts - Johansen - Ovechkin

Subban - Karlsson
Letang - Kronwall
Phaneuf - Carlson

Anderson
Fleury
Luongo


Benn - Seguin - Tarasenko
Forsberg - Getzlaf - Perry
Sedin - Sedin - Hudler
Parise - Toews - Kane

Keith - Suter
Weber - Josi
Giordano - Brodie

Rinne
Quick
Crawford

 

[moomoosoup]

West

Marleau Toews Byfuglien
Benn Getzlaf Perry
Forsberg Nuge-Hopper Kane
Parise Seguin Tarasenko

Giordano Weber
Shattenkirk Keith
Suter Doughty

Rinne
Elliott
Quick

Not in particular orders as far as lines and starting goalies and stuff. Just slotted people in as I thought of them.

 

[ThirdManIn]

What would your legit all-star lineups be (for both conferences)? Actual lineups, no Zemgus Girgensons here, and don't be biased.

Mine:
Eastern Conference
R. Nash S.Crosby J.Voracek
H. Zetterberg S. Stamkos P. Kessel
M. Pacioretty C. Giroux P. Hornqvist
N. Foligno E. Malkin A. Ovechkin

P.K. Subban E. Karlsson
J. Carlson K. Letang
D. Hamilton N. Kronwall

Western Conference
J. Benn T. Seguin V. Tarasenko
P. Marleau F. Forsberg P. Kane
J. Gaudreau R. Getzlaf C. Perry
A. Ladd L. Couture M. Hossa

M. Giordano T.J. Brodie
B. Burns K. Shattenkirk
S. Vatanen D. Keith

So... Weber doesn't make it? How does that even begin to make sense?

Also, Forsberg is a winger. I have no idea why he is still listed as a center.

 

[rangers91*]

Tanner Glass- Sidney Crosby-Jakub Voracek
Tyler Johnson- Steven Stamkos- Rick Nash
Patrik Hornqvist- Evgeni Malkin- Claude Giroux
Alex Ovechkin- John Tavares- Ryan Johansen

Subban- Karlsson
Letang- Kronwall
Hedman-Mcdonaugh

Howard
Lundqvist

Tarasenko-Seguin- John Scott
Benn- Getzlaf- Pat Kane
Perry- Couture-Toews
D.Sedin- H. Sedin-Forsberg

Giordano-Pietrangelo
Weber- Josi
Doughty- Keith


Rinne
Quick

 

[MNRube]

Parise should be every list. PPG pretty much and there are maybe a couple better two-way wings out there. He is a legit allstar and gets no love on HF

 

[Kunta Kinte]

Phaneuf has decent point totals and has the team's highest +/- which is a +14 on a defense that averages a +2. Subban has a worse plus minus than five of his defenseman teammates and only four more points. How has Subban been better? cause he's paid 9 million a year?

Phaneuf has 1 goal... Only "4 more points" and 6 more goals on a 30 game sample, for a dman, its a lot. Phaneuf is 8th on his team scoring, Subban is 3rd.

Phaneuf was known for scoring... he doesnt anymore.

If I have to explain you how Subban is superior than Phaneuf this season (or at anytime) I don't think we could ever have an intelligent argument...

+/- is a **** stats... Pacioretty is +12 on a even team. Desharnais is following at +6 with Emelin at +6 too..

Perhaps our worst defensive players out of the team.

Markov is 0 and Subban -1... for a Even team, thats what you think you will get for your players that play the most.

 

[Bee Sheriff]

Phaneuf has 1 goal... Only "4 more points" and 6 more goals on a 30 game sample, for a dman, its a lot. Phaneuf is 8th on his team scoring, Subban is 3rd.

Phaneuf was known for scoring... he doesnt anymore.

If I have to explain you how Subban is superior than Phaneuf this season (or at anytime) I don't think we could ever have an intelligent argument...

+/- is a **** stats... Pacioretty is +12 on a even team. Desharnais is following at +6 with Emelin at +6 too..

Perhaps our worst defensive players out of the team.

Markov is 0 and Subban -1... for a Even team, thats what you think you will get for your players that play the most.

Goal, assist; the puck got put in the net and he had a part in that happening. Besides, the point here isn't even about scoring. Phaneuf has been a good defenseman for the Leafs this year. +/- is a misunderstood stat, not a bad one. When the proper relativity is applied to it, it can be a good measure. Pacioretty is a great player but there's just better choices.

You're right in saying Subban is only -1 on an even team. But Phaneuf is pretty nicely above his team's average and the points aren't that far off.

 

[ChiHawk21]

East

Nash Crosby Voracek
Pacioretty Stamkos Kessel
Zetterberg Malkin Ovechkin
JVR Giroux Hornqvist
Johnson Tavares

Karlsson-Subban
Ekblad-Hedman
Kronwall-Boychuk
Mcdonough

Price
Bishop
Fluery

Jon Cooper

West

Benn Seguin Tarasenko
Sedin Getzlaf Perry
Parise Toews Kane
Marleau Forsberg Wheeler
Couture Sedin


Keith-Weber
Giordano-Brodie
Suter-Shattenkirk
Doughty

Rinne
Crawford
Quick

Joel Quenneville

Just my guesses so far sure i missed some

 

[Bee Sheriff]

It should be pointed out that the three goalies listed each play one period, so it's not a A-B-C type of role.

 

[Alexander the Gr8]

Take Benn off the list. He's sucked this year.

I'm mostly bitter, and he probably is still the best LW in hockey, but damn, the Stars are terribad this year,

 

[EP40 AKA Lil Wayne]

I want to see east worst vs west worst, that would be more entertaining than an all-star game

 

[ottawa]

I think I got all 15 teams here...I made it somewhat realistic as I expect Subban, Pacioretty and Price to be voted in by fans. And I added Markov as a sign of respect for everything that he's done for the game, he deserves this more than anyone (as much as Jagr)

Eastern Conference
Pacioretty - Crosby - Stamkos
Zetterberg - Malkin - Kessel
Nash - Giroux - Voracek
Johansen - Plekanec - Ovechkin
Jagr - Tavares

Subban - Karlsson
Carlson - Markov
Hamilton - Kronwall
Hedman

Price
Lundqvist

 

[Peen]

I want to see east worst vs west worst, that would be more entertaining than an all-star game

Candidates - Nick Holden, Teddy Purcell, Luke Schenn, Cody Hodgson, Andre Benoit, RJ Umberger, Jan Hejda, Tom Sestito, Zac Rinaldo, Tanner Glass, Brandon McMillan, Deryk Engelland, Jared Boll, Andrew Ference, Jordan Eberle (come at me please), Dan Cleary, Cody McCormick, Adam Burish, Shawn Thornton, TJ Galiardi, Zach Sill, Mike Weber, Andrew Desjardins, John Scott, Brad Stuart, Ben Scrivens, James Reimer, Mike Smith, Viktor Fasth, Ray Emery and Chad Johnson

 

[Bad News Bears]

I think I got all 15 teams here...I made it somewhat realistic as I expect Subban, Pacioretty and Price to be voted in by fans. And I added Markov as a sign of respect for everything that he's done for the game, he deserves this more than anyone (as much as Jagr)

Eastern Conference
Pacioretty - Crosby - Stamkos
Zetterberg - Malkin - Kessel
Nash - Giroux - Voracek
Johansen - Plekanec - Ovechkin
Jagr - Tavares

Subban - Karlsson
Carlson - Markov
Hamilton - Kronwall
Hedman

Price
Lundqvist

FIVE Montreal players? The aim of this thread is to not be biased and ignore the fan voting process.

 

[ottawa]

FIVE Montreal players? The aim of this thread is to not be biased and ignore the fan voting process.

Didn't even realize I added that many...I'd remove Plekanec in that case, replace him with Hornqvist or Bergeron if he picks it up.

Price, Subban and Pacioretty deserve it (regardless of fan voting) due to skill and Markov and Jagr deserve it for the long and successful careers they've had despite uncontrollable obstacles (injuries or having to bail to go play in the KHL)

 

[Bee Sheriff]

I think I got all 15 teams here...I made it somewhat realistic as I expect Subban, Pacioretty and Price to be voted in by fans. And I added Markov as a sign of respect for everything that he's done for the game, he deserves this more than anyone (as much as Jagr)

Eastern Conference
Pacioretty - Crosby - Stamkos
Zetterberg - Malkin - Kessel
Nash - Giroux - Voracek
Johansen - Plekanec - Ovechkin
Jagr - Tavares

Subban - Karlsson
Carlson - Markov
Hamilton - Kronwall
Hedman

Price
Lundqvist

Putting Pacioretty and Subban on the top lines is bad enough, but adding those two on top of it all?

 

[Maplebeasts]

Tanner Glass- Sidney Crosby-Jakub Voracek
Tyler Johnson- Steven Stamkos- Rick Nash
Patrik Hornqvist- Evgeni Malkin- Claude Giroux
Alex Ovechkin- John Tavares- Ryan Johansen

Subban- Karlsson
Letang- Kronwall
Hedman-Mcdonagh

This is a joke right? I mean where is Phil Kessel? Tanner Glass and Tyler Johnson both make it over him? Glass in the all star game in the first place? So many WTF's going through my head right now

 

[Treb]

This is a joke right? I mean where is Phil Kessel? Tanner Glass and Tyler Johnson both make it over him? Glass in the all star game in the first place? So many WTF's going through my head right now

John Scott is in the west line-up.

 

[Maplebeasts]

John Scott is in the west line-up.

Oh dear

 

[dire wolf]

I think I got all 15 teams here...I made it somewhat realistic as I expect Subban, Pacioretty and Price to be voted in by fans. And I added Markov as a sign of respect for everything that he's done for the game, he deserves this more than anyone (as much as Jagr)

Eastern Conference
Pacioretty - Crosby - Stamkos
Zetterberg - Malkin - Kessel
Nash - Giroux - Voracek
Johansen - Plekanec - Ovechkin
Jagr - Tavares

Subban - Karlsson
Carlson - Markov
Hamilton - Kronwall
Hedman

Price
Lundqvist

you know there are 16 teams in the Eastern Conference, right?

 

[Bouboumaster]

East

Nash Crosby Voracek
Pacioretty Stamkos Kessel
Zetterberg Malkin Ovechkin
JVR Giroux Hornqvist
Johnson Tavares

Karlsson-Subban
Ekblad-Hedman
Kronwall-Boychuk
Mcdonough

Price
Bishop
Fluery

Jon Cooper

West

Benn Seguin Tarasenko
Sedin Getzlaf Perry
Parise Toews Kane
Marleau Forsberg Wheeler
Couture Sedin


Keith-Weber
Giordano-Brodie
Suter-Shattenkirk
Doughty

Rinne
Crawford
Quick

Joel Quenneville

Just my guesses so far sure i missed some

So far, I think this is the most accurate.

 

[NotABadPeriod]

I think I got all 15 teams here...I made it somewhat realistic as I expect Subban, Pacioretty and Price to be voted in by fans. And I added Markov as a sign of respect for everything that he's done for the game, he deserves this more than anyone (as much as Jagr)

Eastern Conference
Pacioretty - Crosby - Stamkos
Zetterberg - Malkin - Kessel
Nash - Giroux - Voracek
Johansen - Plekanec - Ovechkin
Jagr - Tavares

Subban - Karlsson
Carlson - Markov
Hamilton - Kronwall
Hedman

Price
Lundqvist

There are 16 teams. And you're missing the Sabres, Hurricanes, and Panthers

 

[ottawa]

you know there are 16 teams in the Eastern Conference, right?

There are 16 teams. And you're missing the Sabres, Hurricanes, and Panthers

Clearly putting thought into my posts is not a requirement

 

[BigBen]

What would your legit all-star lineups be (for both conferences)? Actual lineups, no Zemgus Girgensons here, and don't be biased.

Mine:
Eastern Conference
R. Nash S.Crosby J.Voracek
H. Zetterberg S. Stamkos P. Kessel
M. Pacioretty C. Giroux P. Hornqvist
N. Foligno E. Malkin A. Ovechkin

P.K. Subban E. Karlsson
J. Carlson K. Letang
D. Hamilton N. Kronwall

Western Conference
J. Benn T. Seguin V. Tarasenko
P. Marleau F. Forsberg P. Kane
J. Gaudreau R. Getzlaf C. Perry
A. Ladd L. Couture M. Hossa

M. Giordano T.J. Brodie
B. Burns K. Shattenkirk
S. Vatanen D. Keith

Those are awful teams. I have no idea how the 3 best defensemen in the league (Weber, Suter or Hedman) get left off. And there are much better guys than Hornqvist, Ladd, Gaudreau and Hossa. But the best part is how Foligno is there but not Johansen.

 

[Mitchy]

East

Nash Crosby Voracek
Pacioretty Stamkos Kessel
Zetterberg Malkin Ovechkin
JVR Giroux Hornqvist
Johnson Tavares

Karlsson-Subban
Ekblad-Hedman
Kronwall-Boychuk
Mcdonough

Price
Bishop
Fluery

Jon Cooper

West

Benn Seguin Tarasenko
Sedin Getzlaf Perry
Parise Toews Kane
Marleau Forsberg Wheeler
Couture Sedin


Keith-Weber
Giordano-Brodie
Suter-Shattenkirk
Doughty

Rinne
Crawford
Quick

Joel Quenneville

Just my guesses so far sure i missed some

JVR has been terrible this year. Don't let his scoring totals fool you.

If another Leaf deserves to be an all star, it's Phaneuf or Kadri. They've been our two best players this season.