Leafs under Berube are a hell of alot more likeable than under Keefe.
Both Dubas and Keefe were buffoons. What the hell was Shanahan thinking? Talk about not respecting the game, hiring two completely green people to manage the team?
I used to like Shanahan, but he should be fires because this alone.
Finally looks like a real hockey team again, none of that soft, new-era experiment Dubas was trying to pull off. He was too busy trying to reinvent the wheel and prove he was the smartest guy in the room. Tree deserves GM of the Year for making this look like a real hockey team again jn short order.
Yep. Ultimately so. But as to what Shanahan was thinking...
I think with respect to Dubas, he thought: Lamoriello said he's ready to be the GM, whether in Toronto or somewhere else, and perhaps equally so, Sakic apparently wanted Dubas. On top of Dubas' AHL success and apparent insights as applauded by the likes of LL, I think Shanahan thought he caught lightning in a bottle and that Dubas was a wunderkind in the making.
I still like Shanahan and to the point, if we're bullish on Treliving and everything he's done to redeem the club thus far, then we have to be bullish about Shanahan who stopped short on Dubas and went out and hired Treliving.
In the weeds as it may seem, Shanahan has been very consistent in his fires and hires. He's given everyone the benefit of the doubt and enough time to redeem themselves. And that's Carlyle to Keefe.
Its tough to acknowledge it given the decade of battle scars, but its logically unavoidable and I think sometimes we spite our faces for prioritizing what we want to be true rather than move to the conclusion that is most valid owing to the simplest explanation.
But the simplest explanation I'll look to now is that we just look really different. We're winning every way there is to win. We have a much different looking squad and the swagger of a contender seems evident to me. Looks can be deceiving, but we're healthy, we're happy, and we're entering the playoffs on all manner of team and individual positive punctuation points in a way I don't remember even our Quinn era teams doing.
That our season ending win was against Shanahan's former Stanley Cup winning team and decided by a player we've cast as our latest scapegoat who scored the OT winner, really pushes against type for our club's typical providential playoffs push.
And if there's success, I'd hope the uncomfortable conclusion is, maybe Shanahan sticking to his guns in a certain way was the right path for the club and its necessary maturation process after all. Or, we lose, and he's gone, and we'll get to ask and answer the question again.
Battle-scarred as we all are, we're here to hope again and hope Shanahan was right all along.