If Jake's out, I'd consider dressing 11F and 7D. Drop Robertson (through no fault of his own) and allow a committee of Hyman/Nylander/Mikheyev/Clifford/Engvall to fill in on 3rd line LW. Dress Sandin and Marincin, Marincin for PK duty, 'cause there's no way we see Columbus not come hard the next game. I suspect Keefe will want as little disruption to the pairings as possible, but I can't see how Dermott doesn't become the most important player for the team. I think he has to move up.
Rielly Ceci (your default #1 pair as opposed to the 1A/1B when Jake is available, scary but Ceci just played his best game in ages)
Dermott Holl (Dermott's chance to shine, our closest thing to Jake, physical but no thunder checks, skates better, good at gap control, might compliment Holl well, )
Sandin/Marincin Barrie (5x5 Sandin with Barrie. O zone starts. Sandin is going to have to play conservatively. Huge responsibility to Fs when this pair is on the ice. Our Cs and LWs will have to be aware in our zone of offering support down low. If overwhelmed...Marincin)
I expect Rielly to be worked like a plough horse.
Forwards in our zone being accountable is critical.
I might try to set the tone early:
Clifford Matthews Marner (give Clifford a chance at Jones, can there be a repeat of today's hit?)
Mikheyev Tavares Hyman (a heavy line)
Nylander Kerfoot Kapanen (the fastest line in the series and a threat from anywhere on the ice)
Clifford Engvall Spezza (I want Clifford to fire up this team with early statements, and to deny Columbus the chance to push us around)