I’m neither a novice or casual observer. I know exactly how much more physical and intense it is vs regular season. I didn’t say 2 months of playoff hockey doesn’t take a toll, I’m saying the physical fatigue from it doesn’t carry over through months of offseason into the following season. It’s a fallacy.
I’m also saying that it’s seemingly only Stanley cup finals teams that get these excuses made, and if you actually look at it, they often don’t play many more games than the other teams nobody makes these same claims about. A 3rd round finish vs a Stanley cup finish doesn’t equal meaningful difference in number of games played.
And again, injuries happen to all teams, some considerably worse than the teams that make the cup finals.
For example, Dallas, across the last two years combined has only played 7 less playoff games than Florida has and quite literally no one makes the same excuses for them.