Tasty Biscuits
with fancy sauce
Maybe the movie is a little too clever for its own sake, or maybe this will be another movie that I have a delayed reaction to, or maybe I really do have a Wes Anderson problem. Whatever, I never really connected with Isle of Dogs emotionally; too often I just felt that I was treading water, actively wishing that the movie would pick up the pace and get on to the next scene.
That's disappointing to hear. I had a major Wes Anderson aversion for years until watching Moonrise Kingdom and especially Grand Budapest Hotel, which I thought was fantastic. I despised Fantastic Mr. Fox thought, partly for some of the reasons you mentioned here, and was worried that a return to animation might be a step in the wrong direction.
So, having just seen Isle of Dogs, my reactions definitely trend towards kihei's -- I also share T4M's opinions in loving Moonrise and Kingdom. Both of those movies though, I liked well enough the first time around, but didn't fully appreciate until multiple viewings. The same can be said for Fantastic Mr. Fox, which I thought was just ok, but having seen most of it again recently, enjoyed much more.
In fact, I can't think of a Wes Anderson film which I haven't enjoyed more upon re-watch, and I'm not sure I can pinpoint why. Perhaps it's that, even though he has a unique style, each of his films have just a slightly different heartbeat to them, which is not always obvious first-time around, especially when you're expecting every film to be just like the previous one.