Jevo
Registered User
- Oct 3, 2010
- 3,500
- 394
Wind River (2017)
Nearly a perfect film with a few flaws in "sense." A couple things didn't make a lot of sense, as far as the writing goes, but they're pretty minor overall. Another film with a strong message and fantastic acting. Jeremy Renner was absolutely incredible in this role. I'm honestly shocked he wasn't in Oscar contention for something like this. Elizabeth Olsen was very good, although some of the writing did her no extra favours. The mystery wasn't all that crazy or hard to solve, but the movie isn't so much about the mystery as it is about the message. The final sequence is very powerful. It's both heartwarming and gut wrenching at the same time. Highly recommended.
5-Star Rating Scale: ****1/2
Just a few little things, mostly involving Olsen's character. Things that FBI agents wouldn't do.What did you feel didn’t make sense?
Something fishy about the win, you think?The Shape of Water
Mute woman falls in love with Aquaman, fights to evade evil Michael Shannon, picture wins Oscar.
Yeah, I don't get it either.
Saw Annhilation again with one of my daughters and was blown away, more so than the first time I saw it actually. I think the first time I saw it there was just too much to absorb. I still believe my "new Adam and Eve" theory holds up well. But this time I was better able to see how the parts fit together and to be impressed by the amazing set design and use of music in the film. It's much better directed than I gave it credit for--the mood Garland creates is almost indescribable but very effective. When I reviewed it the first time a couple of hours after I saw it, I gave it a "6" which quickly got transformed the next day into a "7." I'd rate it now an "8B." I find it hard to believe that I will see twenty movies better than Annihilation this year. I don't think that since Hou Hsiao-Hsien's The Assassin have I seen a movie that more rewarded a second look.
Best of '18 so far
1. Foxtrot, Maoz, Israel
2. Annihilation, Garland, UK/US
Okay, but this is put forward as a possible interpretation, in no sense a definitive interpretation, just my two cents.Yeah, there is so much going on in it, more than you'd think even. There are no plans yet on shooting the 2nd book of the Southern Reach Trilogy, Authority, yet right? I know Garland's interpretation isn't exact, but man he puts together a hell of a fun smart "human plight" story with layers. If you wouldn't mind Kihei, could you post with spoiler tags your interpretation or view of the last 15minutes of the movie? Metaphorically (and why not literally, to see if I "missed" anything).
Just a few little things, mostly involving Olsen's character. Things that FBI agents wouldn't do.
And the biggest one is the backup. Even if they couldn't send backup because of Natalie's death not being ruled a homicide, after that Olsen herself kills somebody AND they find another recently deceased body. 3 dead people found within days... okay.
Either way... A 9/10 is still incredible. Loved it. I've seen it twice now.
Just caught Annihilation tonight. Didn’t see any promo material or trailers, so I was absolutely blown away by what I saw. Demands a second watch for sure.Saw Annhilation again with one of my daughters and was blown away, more so than the first time I saw it actually. I think the first time I saw it there was just too much to absorb. I still believe my "new Adam and Eve" theory holds up well. But this time I was better able to see how the parts fit together and to be impressed by the amazing set design and use of music in the film. It's much better directed than I gave it credit for--the mood Garland creates is almost indescribable but very effective. When I reviewed it the first time a couple of hours after I saw it, I gave it a "6" which quickly got transformed the next day into a "7." I'd rate it now an "8B." I find it hard to believe that I will see twenty movies better than Annihilation this year. I don't think that since Hou Hsiao-Hsien's The Assassin have I seen a movie that more rewarded a second look.
Best of '18 so far
1. Foxtrot, Maoz, Israel
2. Annihilation, Garland, UK/US
That's fine about them not caring about Natalie. That makes sense with the plot. Matt, however, was white. And that changes everything.I don’t know exactly how FBI protocol works, so that probably slipped by me. I just assumed she was way out of her element there and just doing what she had to do to solve the case.
The backup thing I thought was explained that the FBI basically didn’t care about murders/disappearances of women on the reservation and weren’t risking man power... I thought that was the jist of why the movie was made... about how many women disappear or are murdered on the reservations without proper investigations.
The end quote was “While missing person statistics are compiled for every other demographic, none exist for Native American women.”
I read an article in the NYT that stated American Indian women are sexually assaulted or raped at four times the national average. They are also 10 times as likely to be murdered than other Americans.
That's fine about them not caring about Natalie. That makes sense with the plot. Matt, however, was white. And that changes everything.