nameless1
Registered User
- Apr 29, 2009
- 18,202
- 1,020
Draft Day (2014) - 8/10
I still like Moneyball better but fantastic sports film this. I'm not a football fan but it's tense and you become really invested in the stakes. The acting from Costner is great and Chadwick Boseman as well in the brief scenes he's in. There are some of the usual generic bits in sports films but they don't really affect this much since it's mostly all about the behind-the-scenes stuff.
Same director as Ghostbusters 1/2 and Stripes.
As a football fan, I can tell you that this movie makes zero sense. Frankly, none of the trades in the end will happen, even in video games. NFL teams uses a point system for picks, and the math just does not work. No sane GM will accept 3 2nd rounders for a top 10 pick, and definitely nobody will trade 3 1st rounders just to move up one spot. If any GM does those trades in real life, not only will he be fired on the spot, the owner will also block those trades. This is no inside look at football; it is not even a fantasy look.
Even if I ignore the nonsensical football decisions, it is a problematic script too. There are too much useless distractions in the script that does nothing to advance the plot, I honestly do not believe that they will find anything more in a last minute background check, and there is no way a guy who traded 3 first round picks will suddenly be a sage that everyone seeks advice from. Frankly, this whole movie is just one propaganda piece to clean up the league's image, which was battered by the concussion scandal and various off-the-field incidents at the time. That is why the fictional GM picked the high character player over the supposed franchise quarterback, which no real GM will actually do, and why the NFL allowed the filmmakers to use team and league logos, when the league is usually very protective of their properties.
I do not disagree that it is well-edited, and Boseman is good in his role, but the movie is a joke, and I have it at a 2 or 3/10. Aside from the unforgivable football mistakes that insult my intelligence, it is just not a good movie, at all.
Last edited: