I know it's a movie thread but after my brief musings on the X-Men and the ongoing discussion of the Hannibal Lectre films I can't resist the urge to plug the respectively related TV series Legion and Hannibal both of which might be better than any of the movies associated with the properties ...
I also think the series, the first two seasons anyway, are better than any movie associated with the property. I was never a fan of
Silence of the Lambs and was always surprised that it received such praise. So I stayed away from
Hannibal until it came up on this thread. Some thoughts:
I thought the first two seasons were beyond amazing, especially the second halves of each. The second season's final few episodes felt like the darkest of fever dreams written by a genuine psychotic. I can’t imagine how NBC decided that this headspace was appropriate for network television, but I am glad that they did. Season two. especially, took me places no movie, nor work of art of any other kind, ever has taken me, an implicit plug for extended story telling.
The third season I thought was a failure on a lot of levels. A “sequel” in all the worst senses of the word, an excuse to try to make more money, nothing else. I could have tolerated the first seven episodes as a kind of closure, but the Red Dragon part was awful. Everything that was subtle and almost unconscious about Hannibal and Will’s relationship turned to obvious and predictable; their brilliant dialogue became an endless string of lazy aphorisms. Some stories are made for two seasons (
Stranger Things is another one). Anything beyond that is just gilding the lily.
In terms of acting the series is beyond first rate though relatively speaking I think Hugh Dancy was the weakest link. Playing a character who possesses a vast emotional palette, Dancy seemed to end up repeating the same gestures and responses over and over. He got predictable and a little boring. Meanwhile, Mikkelsen playing a character with, necessarily, an almost non-existent emotional palette, nonetheless found infinite nuances to express what was going on inside that brilliant but unhinged head. He needed a better foil, an actor strong enough and talented enough to have played Hannibal as well as Will--an equal. Michael Fassbender would have been my ideal choice.
The second best performance in the series was provided by Gillian Anderson. Her almost druggy sense of cool and her ability to deliver dialogue often better than the screenwriters wrote it did wonders for the show. In her "psychiatric" exchanges with Mikkelsen, everything else around me vanished as I just watched them sort of coil and uncoil in counterpoint. Great television.