Portrait of a Lady on Fire (2019) Directed by Celine Sciamma
9A (beautifully done; leisurely paced but rich with incidents)
Marianne is commissioned by a rich patron to paint the portrait of her reluctant daughter Heloise, soon to be married off but not enthusiastic about the prospect. The trappings are 18th century Gothic--Marianne sails to a desolate estate where her subject awaits her in a mansion overlooking a tempestuous sea. Alone together, they get to know one another and bit by bit love blooms. As she did in
Tomboy, a movie about an 11-year-old girl with transgender issues, director Celine Sciamma pitches the filmic equivalent of a perfect game. The direction is beautiful, the mise-en-scene used expertly, the cinematography and lighting worthy of
Barry Lydon, and the script among the best in years. It is impossible not to watch this movie and compare it to
Blue Is the Warmest Colour directed by Abdellatif Kechiche. One movie is made incorporating a traditional male gaze; the other tackles similar material but from the perspective of a female. What's the difference? Take the controversial explicit sex scenes in
Blue Is the Warmest Colour. While they are absolutely necessary, these sex scenes are shot in a way that is very similar to what you might see in a porno movie about lesbians directed for a male, heterosexual audience. Likewise the two central characters never quite get beyond being types that we have seen before at the movies. In contrast, though she incorporates sex scenes, Sciamma engages in no sexual objectification whatsoever. This is a film about a slowly growing relationship between two very specific and believable young women. It's not just that Sciamma handles the sex scenes with a lightness of touch that divorces them from the prurient, she is also way more concerned not with passion and heat, though their importance is not ignored, but with the slowly growing awakenings of each partner, awakenings that lead to the love and desire which make sexual union natural and inevitable. Ultimate
Portrait of a Lady on Fire is a humane and beautiful work that deals with love both as it happens as well as how it is remembered when it departs. Few movies have ever done it better.
subtitles
Best of '19 so far
Portrait of a Lady on Fire, Sciamma, France
An Elephant Sitting Still, Hu, China
High Life, Denis, France/US