Heretic (2024) Directed by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods
7A
Sister Paxton and Sister Barnes, two young Mormon missionaries, knock of the door of Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant) who greets them with good humour and curiosity and invites them in for a piece of blueberry pie that his wife is making. Or is she? Is she even there? First the missionaries' faith is sorely tested, followed closely by their very lives as there seems no way out of Mr. Reed's strangely spooky house. And that blueberry pie only materializes in the damnedest way much later in the movie. The horror builds gradually over the first two acts which consist of increasingly tense scenes where Mr. Reed lectures the girls on religion in a way that is intended to undermine their beliefs and values. His arguments are surprisingly well considered ones, but the presentation becomes increasingly more unhinged. The young missionaries growing sense of alarm escalates because though Mr. Reed remains affable, even seemingly normal, they start to realize they are butterflies stuck in a very diabolical spider's web. The horror escalates in the third act.
I thought
Heretic was a delight, a horror movie that is intellectually engaging and well acted. Mr. Reed has some very firm views on organized religion, craftily arguing that they are all iterations of much older texts that owe more to myth than to divine revelation. He does believe religion serves a purpose but it is anything but a nice one. Hugh Grant is wonderful in the role. All his trademark mannerisms are intact but he has turned their purpose from charm to villainy of a rather engaging kind--that is, until more and more is revealed about what is going on in the basement. It is one of his best performances in years. The more we get in to true horror late in the movie,
Heretic gets a little messy intellectually as well as in terms of gore, but not enough to spoil the fun.
Heretic provides a lively ride, and people might even discuss the ideas and symbolism after leaving the movie theatre.
Best of 2024 so far
- Anora, Baker, US
- Flow, Zilbalodis, Latvia
- Caught by the Tides, Jia, China
- All We Imagine As Light, Kapadia, India
- Do Not Expect Too Much from the End of the World, Jude, Romania
- Green Border, Holland, Poland
- Heretic, Beck and Woods, US
- The Seed of the Sacred Fig, Rasoulof, Germany
- The Shadowless Tower. Lu, China
- Here, Devos, Belgium