City Hunter (1993) - 7/10
A womanizing Private Investigator sneaks aboard a cruise ship that is in the process of being hijacked by terrorists.
Jackie Chan stars as Ryo Saeba, a well known private eye who goes by the nickname "City Hunter". Ryo and his assistant Kaori (Joey Wong) are assigned to find Shizuko Imamura (Kumiko Goto), the daughter of a newspaper mogul who's run away. The search eventually leads them to the luxury cruise liner "Fuji Maru", which features a number of unusual guests: an undercover police officer (Chingmy Yau), a mysterious card shark (Leon Lai), and a ruthless terrorist (Christopher MacDonald)...
City Hunter was directed by Wong Jing, and is based on a Japanese anime of the same name. This was the first (and only) collaboration between the well known director and Jackie Chan, as the two would have a major falling out after the film was completed (more on that later). Despite some drama behind the scenes, City Hunter has gone on to become cult a classic, though it might not be for everyone.
The film's plot revolves around a scenario similar to Die Hard (1988) or Under Siege (1992), where Jackie's Ryo Saeba has to use his special fighting skills to battle terrorists and free hostages in an enclosed location. The film has good action sequences and gun play, and Jackie has memorable fights with both Gary Daniels and Richard Norton. Actor/musician Leon Lai plays non-canonical character Kao Ta, a gambler who uses playing cards as projectile weapons, and has some cool moments in the film (he and Jackie don't share any screen time, unfortunately).
However, the film is most well known for its
extremely cheesy comedy. City Hunter beats the audience over the head with its non-stop humor that is often kindergarten level, like a man's pants falling down or someone getting hit in the face with a cake. Jackie Chan plays a self-serving nincompoop of a private investigator, who spends the majority of the movie trying to woo various women and searching for food. There's one quick moment where he finally finds a piece of bread, only to trip on the stop step of a staircase which results in the bread flying out of his hand (we see this from two angles, once in slow motion).
Most famously, this movie has an extended parody scene of the SNES video game "Street Fighter II", which includes Jackie Chan dressing in drag as he cosplays the female character Chun-Li. City Hunter has some truly ridiculous moments, and some of the humor doesn't work. A lot of it does though, and because the comedy is so rampant, a joke not landing isn't a buzzkill because the audience is usually seconds away from the next gag.
I must be a very childish person because I find some of the stupidest moments of this movie to be absolutely hysterical. Jackie Chan doesn't feel the same, though. Upon its release, he spoke out against the film - specifically its comedy - which caused a feud between he and director Wong Jing. This culminated in Jing making the 1995 film "High Risk", which portrays a Jackie Chan-spoof character as a drunk, cowardly actor who relies heavily on a stunt double. That is a lot of effort to go to over a feud.
Though I enjoy the City Hunter, I can see Jackie's point. The humor is
so campy and the film leans into it so heavily that it has great potential to alienate some audience members. This is a movie I could see someone shutting off after 5 minutes, or alternatively returning to dozens of times after the initial viewing. I fall into the latter category, but your milage may vary.
Overall, City Hunter is a one-of-a-kind movie. It has great action and a familiar action plot, but comedy that's so tragically unfunny that it ends up being hysterical. Those who can get into the comedy will likely be fans for life, but others may wonder how the heck Jackie Chan ended up in this film. It's a "love it" or "hate it "type movie. I love it.