Killers of the Flower Moon (2023) Directed by Martin Scorsese
5B
It is praiseworthy that Martin Scorsese has chosen to make a movie about an abomination that has been virtually whitewashed (right verb) from American history. At the turn of the century in Oklahoma, the Osage tribe found themselves millionaires over night when the land that they had been forced to settle on erupted with oil. It wasn't long, though, before unscrupulous white men found unconventional ways to take over the money. This included marrying into Native American families and if that didn't work quickly enough, murdering the aboriginal men and mostly women who stood in the way of the perpetrators' inheritance. Oklahoma law simply looked the other way.
Killers of the Flower Moon focuses on Ernest Burkhart (Leonardo DiCapriio) who comes home after the war in Europe and is immediately offered a job by his uncle William Hale (Robert Di Nero). Hale, who claims to be a great friend of the Osage, is actually the brains behind the operation of stealing their money. He has no scruples whatsoever, and Ernest is just the sort of useful moron that he needs to carry out his orders. . While Hale wants Ernest to target Molly (Lily Gladstone), Ernest genuinely falls in love with her and they eventually marry. But that doesn't mean he won't remain deeply complicit in his uncle's schemes, which include setting up murders and stupidly assisting in the harm that may be done to his wife. So this is an important story and one that needs to be told. In its favour,
Killers of the Flower Moon contains some great performance and scenes of real power.
However, the film possesses some structural weaknesses that are hard to overlook. This three-hour, 26 minute movie only really becomes gripping in its last hour or so, about the time Jesse Plemons' FBI agent arrives in town. Until that point we get more story than we need to make the point about how cruel and hateful the attempted cash grab is. It's not just a problem of excessive length, though. Scorsese is noted for his expertly edited and perfectly paced movies (
Mean Streets; Taxi Driver: Goodfellas; Raging Bull, et al)--
Killers of the Flower Moon is anything but well paced. Indeed the editing seems haphazard, almost arbitrary some of the time, lacking the tight rhythm that would supercharge this story about racist greed. And, unfortunately, the more exciting the movie eventually becomes, the more it drifts away from the plight of the Osage and focuses instead on our two loathsome scumbag protagonists, both white guys, one a heartless snake and the other a moronic weasel. I kept thinking, why am I watching these two schmucks? It is Molly, not Hale or Ernest, who the audience cares about, and Gladstone gives a magnificent performance that outshines everyone else in the film. If Scorsese had made her the centrepiece of the story,
Killers of the Flower Moon would have been much more powerful and much more revealing about what took place in Oklahoma. Instead, he made another gangster movie.