Licorice Pizza (2021) Directed by Paul Thomas Anderson 5A
I have never been a fan of director Paul Thomas Anderson. My favourite film of his is Junun, basically Radiohead's brilliant Jonny Greenwood jamming with a bunch of Indian musicians, not exactly one of Anderson's primary or even secondary calling cards. (Full disclosure, I also liked Phantom Thread, and, no, I didn't like Punch-Drunk Love). I waver between thinking Anderson quirkily weird or weirdly quirky, one of the two, for sure. Whatever way you cut it I almost never like his movies, though. Set in the still hopeful early '70s, Licorice Pizza has a lot going for it. Not the least, there are brilliant break out performances by Cooper Hoffman (Philip Seymour Hoffman's son) and especially by Alana Haim. Hoffman plays Gary, a charming, confident young entrepeneur and Haim plays Alana (same name) a young woman still trying to find her footing in life. As a result Gary's incessant charm offensive, they begin a relationship, a sweet but stormy one, one in which you root for both characters. But here's the rub: Gary is 15 years old and Alana is 25 years old. Surprisingly, most reviews don't make a big deal about it. But think of the uproar if the genders were reversed and Gary was 25 and Alana 15. It doesn't help that the 15 year old is mature beyond his years and gets Alana pretty much to do his bidding, including in some situations with a high cringe factor. It also doesn't help that Alana seems to bumble through life weakly, lacking self-confidence and agency. Add an unforced error of racist humour and a gay stereotype and it becomes hard to deduce what Anderson thinks he is doing here.
Licorice Pizza is less of a narrative than a string of random vignettes glopped together in place of a plot. These vignettes usually focus on yucky men (William Holder and Barbra Streisand's ex, Jon Peters) and give ample opportunity for big stars to steal a scene or two (Sean Penn and Bradley Cooper, respectively). Cooper is indeed a hoot as the self-centred, volatile former hair dresser, and his vignette contains a superb scene about a truck that has run out of gas but not out of thrills. Lovely cinematography, also. So there is much to like here...and much to simply puzzle over, too.
Sidenote: The odd thing here is that Anderson could have made Gary 18-years-old and the movie wouldn't have skipped a beat. So he obviously wants that edge in there. No doubt there is a double standard here, but it is a weird (or is that quirky?) one. As a 15 year old, I'm not sure many guys would object to being seduced by the right older woman. Just sayin'....
I haven't seen this but I had no idea there was 15 year old having a relationship with a 25 year old in it. You're right to point out that most reviews seem to not point this out age gap, I had figured that he was 18 since that's roughly how old the actor is. You're also right to point out that if PTA reversed the genders in the relationship there would be a pretty big uproar, probably something similar to the whole Cuties controversy last year.