Some brief order in madness, I went back and completed Sergio Martino's first run in the genre and rewatched his (more) traditionnal early gialli. After that I should go back to random stuff and watch a few I haven't seen before.
The Case of the Scorpion's Tail (
La coda dello scorpione, Martino, 1971) – Martino followed his first vice film with another very conventional giallo that's just a lot less convincing to me (I'm sure many fans of the genre must appreciate this one just as much though, and it's still a very important early 70s giallo). It's probably the fact that every character here is unpleasant and unlikable, coupled with obvious borrowings from better films (
Blow-Up,
Psycho), but it just doesn't really work for me, even though the film has undeniable qualities and should work as an effective entry in the genre (it has pretty much every elements you could think of – and it nicely hijacks the argento-ian
forgotten detail /
focus on a detail). Things to learn from this film: solve the case and get the girl, and if a car speeds towards you to kill you, just drop to the ground (!).
3.5/10
All the Colors of the Dark (
Tutti i colori del buio, Martino, 1972) – Probably the most ambitious of Martino's early gialli run, but also his weaker in execution. The film has great atmospheric moments, but also some really cheesy stuff. Whereas the cult scene in
Short Night of Glass Dolls was short and restrained (and relevant), here Martino goes full cheese and kind of ruins the film's pace and tone (early dreamy/hallucinatory trips are not so convincing either). Also, Bruno Nicolai's score – a favorite of many giallo fans – is in my opinion one of his worst. Nicolai, once a close collaborator of Morricone, scored a huge number of gialli, always with debatable and uneven results, but here it stays pretty weak throughout (he even proposes a variation of the
Rosemary's Baby lullaby, only underlying the film's major debt to Polanski's film). It has many interesting elements (sight, eyes, reflections), and I think it is more easily opened to different readings than most films of the genre (even though it's still limited by overexplanations), but it suffers from its weaker moments, and from a serious case of Fenech ovedoing it (but she's still amazing). I was very surprised to see that I had the film at 7/10 on IMDB. I graded all the others pretty close to my original scores, but here I can't go above
5/10.
Torso (I corpi presentano tracce di violenza carnale, Martino, 1973) – I guess someone thought that this time they went too far with the original title (which Google translates to
The bodies show traces of rape, but should probably be
sexual violence). It's not really clear what the torso is supposed to refer to, but there's quite a few of those, ifyaknowwhatImean. Overall a pretty conventional giallo, Martino still shows his ability to break tone (though not as much as in his second vice film) and includes a pretty long sequence where one of the girls hides in the house while the killer cleans his mess up, unaware of her presence – without a doubt the best moments of the film. The film opens with promises of reflexivity, but doesn't really deliver – it still makes for a few interesting bits in the first part and unfolds into a fixation on the eyes and sight from the murderer, but without much to work with. The film marks the end of a great series of gialli by Martino. He'll come back to the genre a few times, but never with as much panache.
4/10