Knies vs Slafkovsky vs Cuylle

[Lafleurs Guy]

Don't let the fence hurt you too bad.

Slaf is my choice.

That doesn’t mean I can’t like Knies though.

 

[93gilmour93]

Is this something Maple Leafs fan share proudly amongst themselves or is this a burner account who forgot he repeated himself?

Great minds think alike

 

[the paisanos guy]

I'd probably go Knies actually, but will be fun to watch how they both progress over the next few years. interesting to see both Habs and Leafs fans pretty mixed on it haha

 

[LivingRentFree]

It’s Knies

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Close one. I'll take Knies by a hair, I think his instincts and hands around the net are just a bit better. I do like Slafkovsky's ceiling a bit more, as his shot from distance could make him a lethal perimeter weapon down the road. But I think Knies is the more sure bet to be consistent 30+30 guy. Both of these guys will be premier power forwards in a league for a long time.

I think Cullye is pretty underrated though, but he's just not quite on the same level of these two IMO.

 

[Rob Brown]

Is this something Maple Leafs fan share proudly amongst themselves or is this a burner account who forgot he repeated himself?

Why do you seem to be annoyed that people are sharing relevant information in the context of the poll? Lol.

 

[The Gr8 Dane]

Slaf is a better playmaker and Knies a better goalscorer especially in tight around the net , It's close

Both hit at around the same clip , Slaf's powerforward game is coming along nicely , both great players , I wonder if Knies gets a bigger contract than Slaf because of goalscoring , probably

 

[NyQuil]

Pretty good poll.

Knies I think but could change my mind.

 

[GrandmaCookie]

Why do you seem to be annoyed that people are sharing relevant information in the context of the poll? Lol.

I’m not annoyed, just find it hilarious leafs fan are spilling over themselves in a hurry to repeat the same stuff. Lol.

 

[A1LeafNation]

Knies all day for me right now.

His hits and shoots and can fight a little.

4 players with 25+G and 150+ hits.

Holloway Wilson BTkachuk Knies.

These are the top power forwards in the league currently.

 

[Captain97]

Slaf.
Because Knies plays with Matthew's and Marner + Slaf is Younger and Only few less point.

side note Knies is a great find for where he was picm.

 

[biturbo19]

I think it's really close between Knies and Slafkovsky. I think there's a little bit more headroom with Slaf, but the consistency isn't quite there the way it is for Knies. And i like the way Knies game consistently brings everything you want in a complementary, goal-scoring power forward. Yes...he plays with better players, but it's not like Slaf is playing with scrubs, and i think what Knies brings to a line is pretty underrated in how much more effective it can make the players around him.

But really...i wouldn't fault anyone for picking either of the two. Can entirely justify the choice either way i think. Cuylle on the other hand, is a decent player, but not really in the same echelon as the other two i don't think.

 

[loadie]

Went with Slaf, but Knies is one hell of a player, the Leafs really lucked out with that draft pick

 

[Strangle]

Knies doesnt outproduce slafkovsky enough to overturn the arguement of who they play with. Suzuki and Caufield are great, but even big habs homers won’t say they are better than Marner and Matthews during the season.

If knies had like 59 in 69 I think you could make the argument but with only a 3 point gap in 1 extra game, you gotta to Slaf.

I bet they would if you put the magical words “contracts included” in the poll title lmfao