Voted Tkachuk again before this poll gets shut down as well for a lopsided result.
But post a third poll after next game and I may reconsider.
But post a third poll after next game and I may reconsider.
Knies vs Brady Tkachuk
- Thread starter KniesMadeBradyCry
- Start date
- Status
I’ll do my best!Voted Tkachuk again before this poll gets shut down as well for a lopsided result.
But post a third poll after next game and I may reconsider.
Do you guys remember Stutzle vs Matthews?
Also, I started the Willy>Timmy poll and got laughed at too. Seems like I was also right about that.
- May 20, 2015
- 502
- 322
OP is a joke. How many more useless attempt to troll thread need to be made and spamming this board.
GIN ANTONIC
Registered User
I think most people would still take Stutzle over Nylander considering he's 6 years younger, plays C, produces at a very similar rate, and is signed to a way better contract.
Nylander is great though
Well, he’s been better in the reg season, and playoffs. I go by results, not a 4 nations tournament
Knies would be a good addition to the US in next years Olympics in place of Kreider, but he isn't better than B. Tkachuk.
GIN ANTONIC
Registered User
How was Knies better in the reg season or playoffs?
Brady scored at a better rate in the reg season with same amount of goals in fewer games on a worse team and in the playoffs he had 7 points in 6 games, with 4 goals while Knies has 5 points in 7 games and same amount of goals. I don't think you understand numbers or most things hockey related.
Last edited:
I do remember seeing a poll like that. I remember it was when Stutzle outscored Matthews. The poll also specified cap hits be taken into account.
Quite different than Spezza and Wellwood.
I will give you Stutzle v Matthews is a bit silly but Stützle has outscored everyone of Willy's seasons at the same age well playing the more high demand position.... I think everyone would pick Stutzle over Nylander unless you are doing something like who would you pick for the next year or two. But career wise Timmy is almost certainly the superior player.
Willy
D+1 AHL
D+2 22 6 7 13
D+3 81 22 39 61
D+4 82 20 41 61
D+5 54 7 20 27
Timmy
D+1 53 12 17 29
D+2 79 22 36 58
D+3 78 39 51 90
D+4 75 18 52 70
D+5 82 24 55 79
Willy doesnt even get close to a point per game until he is two years older then Timmy is now.
Now even if you look at Brady and Knies at the same age
Knies this year 78 29 29 58 Brady at the same age 79 30 37 67
SensontheRush
Never said it was Sunshine
Why does this guy care more about getting a rise out of Sens fans than supporting their own team?
Weird and sad.
Weird and sad.
GIN ANTONIC
Registered User
Well I do hate the Leafs organization and their fanbase in general, but that doesn't change any of the stats or facts that were presented in my post. I'm happy to give praise to players who deserve it. Knies is great. So is Willy. So are a bunch of Leafs players. You're just trying to get people to go against facts and logic on this one and it's not gonna work out for you.
NyQuil
Big F$&*in Q
You might say the Sens are LivingRentFree in his head.
Golden_Jet
Registered User
- Sep 21, 2005
- 23,155
- 16,303
Good find @NyQuil on LivingRentFree changing their username to the OP.
Golden_Jet
Registered User
- Sep 21, 2005
- 23,155
- 16,303
Sorry I’ve learnt reading LivingRentFree posts aren’t the best way to spend my time.
- Status
