Player Discussion Kirby Dach: Welcome to Montreal part 2

[cave troll]

And if he doesn't continue like this?

Same can be said about every player in the roster. What if they don't continue like this?
What if they suddenly become top NHL players? What if next year we're contenders? What if..what if...?
New talents will come in next years and some players who failed to achieve will be dismissed. Dach and Newhook are surely among them if they play under expectations. So what's negative about that?

 

[Estimated_Prophet]

Same can be said about every player in the roster. What if they don't continue like this?
What if they suddenly become top NHL players? What if next year we're contenders? What if..what if...?
New talents will come in next years and some players who failed to achieve will be dismissed. Dach and Newhook are surely among them if they play under expectations. So what's negative about that?

You give more credence to the negative bias and dismiss the positive.....everything is wrong with that as it is devoid of nuance and feels more antagonistic than it does analytical.

You dismiss the positive with "What if they don't continue like this" as a nebulous blanket statement but you fail to do the same with the negative bias.....it is a grossly engineered methodology that doesn't permit nuanced discussion. The fact that you doubled down on it is both troubling and very telling but very consistent with your user name....is that coincidental?

Your contributions are welcome and I am sure you are capable of delivering a more balanced opinion.

 

[cave troll]

The only neboulous blankets are put by posters who are decieveing themselves with thinking that these roster players have some hidden treasures ready to be uncovered and explode.
When we got Dach we were chanting "yes! steal"!, "wow, 3rd OA is ours" and noone was bothered by the fact that on the same forum there were people who were writing " thank god, good riddance!" First ones didn't watch him game after game, second ones did.
It's a player which was booted by the club who drafted him, cause they deemed him not good for a rebuild they are doing. This is the reality.
When Dach got injured a year ago, people who were writing that it's a serious injury and that it will be dubious Dach will return to his pre injury form quickly after rehabiltation where deemed amateurs with "ACL surgery is a routine. no big deal. he'll be as good as new" replies. Now he needs how many games to be called "as good as new"? 30? 40? 50?
Influx of new, more talented forwards forward in our roster in next years is a fact and guys like Dach or Newhook will have to work hard for a new contract. That's the reality. You can call it negativity if you want.

 

[OldCraig71]

I'm sure the media in Montreal is starting to ask questions about Dach's play and he is connected just as all the players are. They say they don't pay attention to outside noise but that's just media training talking. I want to see him respond with his play on the ice.

 

[Estimated_Prophet]

The only neboulous blankets are put by posters who are decieveing themselves with thinking that these roster players have some hidden treasures ready to be uncovered and explode.
When we got Dach we were chanting "yes! steal"!, "wow, 3rd OA is ours" and noone was bothered by the fact that on the same forum there were people who were writing " thank god, good riddance!" First ones didn't watch him game after game, second ones did.
It's a player which was booted by the club who drafted him, cause they deemed him not good for a rebuild they are doing. This is the reality.
When Dach got injured a year ago, people who were writing that it's a serious injury and that it will be dubious Dach will return to his pre injury form quickly after rehabiltation where deemed amateurs with "ACL surgery is a routine. no big deal. he'll be as good as new" replies. Now he needs how many games to be called "as good as new"? 30? 40? 50?
Influx of new, more talented forwards forward in our roster in next years is a fact and guys like Dach or Newhook will have to work hard for a new contract. That's the reality. You can call it negativity if you want.

You are not demonstrating any ability to comprehend my concerns and it looks very intentional and by design......enjoy your time here but I will not be interacting with you any longer.