He’s a very good hockey player and one of my favourite players even with the islanders. Having said that, sometimes captains need to bring other elements to the game, especially if he’s playing 2C.
Crosby - can be a pest, play a very chippy game and show his frustration, heck he even scraps when need be.
Ovi - Can change the game with a bullet shot, but can change a game and an entire playoffs with big hits.
Iginla, Morrow, Chara, Getzlaf, heck even Lidstrom, etc - Don’t need to scrap but try something else to change the game. Block a shot do something else to change the game. Don’t get laid out or watch your goalie get runned over and just go back to the bench. I see more aggressiveness in Matthews as he matures and not taking sh** from opponents anymore. Tavares is a great player but if he really signed here for a cup run, he needs to bring a different element when he’s not putting up points or even handling the puck well.