Diaz was a good pickup. He had a good game. He is no real threat however to ever break into a good team's top four--and this 'quite easily better' remark of yours after only one game strikes me as either biased or premature. Should take some time at least to get a better picture of just how he fits. Diaz was never anywhere near breaking into Montreal's top 4 and he couldn't do it in Vancouver. Moore should be able to do it some day but it's not likely to be with the Rangers if Staal sticks around.
Anyway whatever problems that the Moore-Del Zotto tandem was having defending in their own end pretty much disappeared when Klein replaced Del Zotto. Since then Moore has been a lot more solid in his own end and much more noticeable attacking the other end--though his insertion back into the pwp mix in the last month or so has not done a lot for that.
Why does a player have to be in the top 4 to be considered to crack a teams top 6? I've watched Diaz over his career in Montreal. I know the game he plays. Why do you think I'm judging him off of one single game? Guess what, I'm not.
Diaz is a better player then Moore. Everyone seemed to be shocked last night when he played well, I wasn't, I expected it. In fact, I was furious that it took an injury to Moore for Diaz to even get playing time when he is clearly the better player right now.
Moore may have future top-4 potential. I don't think he ever puts that together, but to each there own. It is true, Moore's ceiling is higher, since Diaz is older. But Diaz is a fantastic #5/6 right now. He's very steady. I know he'll never be a true #4, but I'm not asking him to be. In my opinion, for most of the year, Moore has not played well. He's settled in since Klein got here, but is still not anything special. Diaz is the better player. I have no doubt and that comes from watching him over the course of the past few seasons, not one Ranger game. Which again, was not some sort of anomaly. That is the type of player he is.
Also, if you think I'm lying and still don't know anything about Diaz, go over to the Habs board and ask their fans what they think of him. They'll tell you exactly the same thing I'm saying. The guy is a legit bottom pairing guy. He sure as hell isn't a #7