Someone in the main boards thread yesterday said something along the lines of "there are only like 5 total fanbases right now that don't hate their coach" and that's about as truthful a fact as you'll read on HF. Even if we added Sullivan or Carle, I'm not sure the majority would've liked their performance after a few months.
Blashill is a very meh pick for me right now. I'm waiting to hear his interview to get a firmer grasp on how I should feel about him at this point. But I'm not expecting much and I wouldn't expect much out of almost anyone the Hawks went with. It's up to him and his new coaching staff to surprise us.
Also, he was coaching some awful Wings teams during an era where they were tearing things down. This Hawks team isn't great, but we're not tearing things down at this point, we're trying to build things up. That's a big difference. Not to mention coaches generally perform better on their 2nd and 3rd attempts than what they were able to accomplish on their 1st opportunities.