Jake Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

[Xspyrit]

Reinhart’s only a year younger though, and despite a huge year with a nearly 25% shooting percentage, he’s historically been a worse producer.

Barkov makes Reinhart better, just like he made Huberdeau better. Now insert Guentzel with Barky and he would do close to same as Reinhart, hence I'll vote Jake.

Guentzel has been attached to Crosby pretty much all the way. Went to Carolina and played with Aho and Jarvis

The question is "who's better?" so even if Guentzel had better production when Reinhart was in Buffalo, the last 3 years shows that Reinhart has the edge now (Reinhart has 121 goals and 122 assists the last 3 seasons combined, Guentzel has 106 goals and 128 assists)

 

[CanadienShark]

Reinhart

 

[WaitingForThatCab]

Guentzel is definitely the more proven goal scorer. Reinhart has been flat out elite defensively in Florida.

Tough call. Voting even.

 

[behemolari]

How is this different than Guentzel playing with Crosby/Malkin?

Voted even…but I’m very interested to see how Guentzel performs next season away from Pittsburgh. Good poll, OP!

Crosby was a product of Guentzel obviously, getting paid now more than him

 

[SeanMoneyHands]

We likely find out next year as Jake is likely playing with Anthony Cirelli. The first time in his career where he's not with a star center.

 

[Howboutthempanthers]

Barkov makes Reinhart better, just like he made Huberdeau better. Now insert Guentzel with Barky and he would do close to same as Reinhart, hence I'll vote Jake.

Barkov made Huberdeau better as much as he makes Tkachuk better. He played on separate lines from both players 5 on 5. And played the PP with both players.