I'm still very much open to bringing him back on a 3-6 year deal... He just is what he is. A 40-50 point, 20-25 goal scorer who is going to be invisible for half of the season, and blow you away for the other half. He's very consistent in his production season-to-season but the inconsistency game-to-game is insane.
Depending on the term I'm not comfortable paying him more than ~5m. He's not young enough where there's a higher upside and he's never stepped up like you hoped he would have in his numerous opportunities. Our pro scouting has been really good on middle-6 guys who can come here in an elevated role and perform (Heinen, Zacha, Coyle, etc.), he can be replaced.
Would rather keep a sure thing but at this point I wouldn't be surprised if he's already out the door.