This probably belongs in the draft thread purely for perspective, but we're basically saying that MDC is not ready and perhaps needs at least a year in the AHL. In his draft year I suspect anyone suggesting that the Isles take Robby Fabbri would have been run out of town. Meanwhile, he's playing regular minutes for STL, and his coach said he was one of the team's best forwards in the 1st round series win. But hopefully MDC is just one of those bigger forwards who need a bit more time.
Let's face it, you can "re-draft" every draft year, year after year, and have a different order. Even in Yakupov's year when Snow allegedly offered all his picks for the #2, Ryan Murray, that probably would have worked out well for the Islanders in hindsight. Or maybe picking Morgan Rielly who went the next pick? Is Filip Forsberg the best player in that first round? Went 11th? In a re-draft it's possible 3rd rounders Shane Ghostisbere and Freddy Anderson go in the top 5.
Not picking on you or your post. I remember Don Cherry being upset that the Leafs took Nylander instead of Fabbri who "played in their backyard in Mississauga (part of Toronto, essentially). Yes, Cherry is incredibly biased, hates europeans and maybe he's wrong since Nylander looks like a budding star). St. Louis has some really nice picks recently, Tarasenko (Russian factor) fell to them, they took Fabbri and Jaden Schwartz in the mid-1st round as well. Parayko.
Isles need a few of these players to hit, the outside the 1st round. Like 2008 with Hamonic, Martin, etc.
I like Dal Colle. Fornabaio wrote that he struggled for 5on5 ice time because of turnovers and he didn't trust him. He's not a stellar AHLer yet and not yet an NHLer. Patience. He may not "get it" and maybe he doesn't become any more than Taylor Pyatt. Maybe Steve Bernier (also a mid 1st rounder).
It's so damn tough. I remember watching Cogliano and thinking Fabbri was a clone of him. Small, fast, offensively skilled. Cogliano's become a much different player now that he's matured, still en effective player.
I see Dal Colle and hope for Alex Tanguay. Unspectacular, great support player who can play with great players, can pass, can score, will need to learn to be responsible defensively. Tanguay broke into the league and played with Forsberg, Sakic, Drury, Hejduk and fit right in, had a long career.
Well, it depends on how you rate NHL readiness as opposed to upside. As an athlete, Ho-Sang is way more ready than Dal Colle. Dal Colle's hockey sense will make him the better player if he ever develops athletically. Who knows whether that will ever happen.
I agree with this. And it's because Ho-Sang has NHL-hands, NHL-speed and hockeyIQ. He'll need to get stronger and learn defense, those slick moves won't work in the NHL as much and we all love neutral zone turnovers in the NHL, don't we? Ever hear a coach say "manage the puck"? Ho-Sang will drive Capuano (any NHL coach) crazy with his high-risk play, for sure. But he can do things with that puck that few can. Hopefully he can be like Johnny Gaudreau and less like Rocco Grimaldi.
They are different players, MDC and Ho-Sang and I agree on different development paths/timing. Both good players, both should help the Islanders.