What the hell differences does it make? Last I checked 'stache doesn't use hfboards to make decisions on who does and doesn't stay in his lineup. You don't make those calls so what's the point of making a thread about this??? Suppose everyone says "YES"...does that change if he's going to be playing in the O?
Its a discussion board to discuss things on it. Thats the point. just like posting prospective lineups on here, we know it doesnt matter in the end. Using that thinking we should just delete our accounts and let hfboards die.