If you were the Canucks, who would you trade: Pettersson or Miller?

[syz]

Miller is trying to get the best out of the team, better than being passively mediocre like Pettterson is ok with doing.

Debatable, but nobody knows the specifics of what's going on. All I know is we've seen Miller snap on teammates a few times over the years, so it wouldn't surprise me if he's the type of guy who wears out his welcome. Like the player equivalent of the Torts-type coach. Your co-worker being an asshole is no different than your boss being an asshole--at some point they make you want to stop showing up for work.

 

[SeanMoneyHands]

Easily trade Pettersson, he would also net a better return. Miller is the better player, the better leader and the more well rounded player despite being older.

 

[rypper]

Miller is trying to get the best out of the team, better than being passively mediocre like Pettterson is ok with doing.

Miller was directly responsible for 2 goals against last night when he just didn't feel like playing defense.

Pettersson isn't hurting you when he's not scoring.

 

[SeanMoneyHands]

Miller>>>>Petty.


Petty hasn't been the same player since re-signing last season.

 

[Sky04]

Miller was directly responsible for 2 goals against last night when he just didn't feel like playing defense.

Pettersson isn't hurting you when he's not scoring.

1 game, Pettersson on the other hand hurts you in the playoffs by being a complete ghost.

 

[dirtydanglez]

trade them both.

 

[Regal]

1 game, Pettersson on the other hand hurts you in the playoffs by being a complete ghost.

Eh, it was one playoffs. He was great in the bubble. I don’t think there’s anything about Pettersson’s game that suggests he can’t succeed in the playoffs. His shitty play last year was a continuation of his play in the last 1/3 of the season. Pettersson isn’t a passive player when he’s on, so while his drop in play is a definite concern, if the team is confident he’ll get back to his previous level, I don’t think the playoffs should be a concern.

 

[Sky04]

Eh, it was one playoffs. He was great in the bubble. I don’t think there’s anything about Pettersson’s game that suggests he can’t succeed in the playoffs. His shitty play last year was a continuation of his play in the last 1/3 of the season. Pettersson isn’t a passive player when he’s on, so while his drop in play is a definite concern, if the team is confident he’ll get back to his previous level, I don’t think the playoffs should be a concern.

1/3rd of last season, all playoffs and all season this year after signing an 11.6m contract? If I'm Miller I'd be pissed too, completely mailed it in after getting paid.

 

[rypper]

Hey he didn't start mailing it in at 11.6 until this season.

 

[Ben White]

I can’t imagine they’d trade EP even through he’s been struggling for almost a year now. EP has the talent level of a true #1 franchise C which is extremely difficult to come by. Miller is a strong player, a 1C light or great 2C, but he doesn’t have that superstar ceiling.

 

[La Bamba]

From an Oiler fan perspective, Miller is a much better player for them. I can't remember a single moment during the Oilers/Canucks series where I noticed Petersson. His contract is atrocious and is trending towards a Huberdeau type deal

 

[SillyRabbit]

From an Oiler fan perspective, Miller is a much better player for them. I can't remember a single moment during the Oilers/Canucks series where I noticed Petersson. His contract is atrocious and is trending towards a Huberdeau type deal

This seems to be a common sentiment from Oilers fans.

Another Oilers fan said the following:

In our series vs Vancouver, we feared JT Miller. We feared Boeser, Lindholm, Joshua, Garland. We did not fear Pettersson.

Soft and easy to remove from the puck. He played with no urgency, no focus. It was like he couldn't wait for the off season. In our office, we called him Western Marner.

Miller played with a fire in his belly and he made his presence felt every time he took the ice.

In a series with razor thin margins, Pettersson's performance may have made that difference, and thank God that went our way.

 

[TheDawnOfANewTage]

Debatable, but nobody knows the specifics of what's going on. All I know is we've seen Miller snap on teammates a few times over the years, so it wouldn't surprise me if he's the type of guy who wears out his welcome. Like the player equivalent of the Torts-type coach. Your co-worker being an asshole is no different than your boss being an asshole--at some point they make you want to stop showing up for work.

Yep, depends how it’s communicated and Miller doesn’t seem to play up to such a demanding attitude. People seem to respect MacKinnon, for instance, because he lives what he preaches.

Anyway- I’d trade both, no joke. If you wanna win a cup- both these guys getting along could maybe do it, but by themselves neither is the guy, but both would have to be the guy. That never works anyways, I feel like- one dude gets traded, all the pressure is on the other homie, and then he eventually wants out as well. Whole thing is soured.

 

[CanucksSayEh]

I don't think either gets moved and this is all mostly bs, but I know damn sure who I'd rather play against.

 

[5 14 6 1]

To be real, I ask Quinn Hughes what he thinks.

 

[Coffee]

To be real, I ask Quinn Hughes what he thinks.

Didn’t expect the Oilers guy to have the best idea in the Canucks thread