If MTL/TOR/OTT had a redraft, what would your top 10 look like?

[Nogatco Rd]

Not having Matthews and Marner 1 and 2 invalidates the thread.

Do you have a top 10 to share or did you just stop by to shit on other people’s lists?

 

[NyQuil]

Nick Cousins has a Cup ring so I guess that puts him at the top of the list. (actual)

 

[Pablo El Perro]

Shouldn't this be on the fantasy forum?

 

[Pierce Hawthorne]

Hutson at #3 was enough to get this thread locked up lmao.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Not having Matthews and Marner 1 and 2 invalidates the thread.

Where’s your picks.
So far mostly leaf fans complaining, without providing a list

 

[Atomos2]

What is potential about a 90 point season at 20 and pacing for 100 at 22?

Over multiple 90 point seasons and a selke finalist?

Maybe the fact that you have to add the kid’s age after every stat

Also did you seriously just ask what is potential about pacing for 100? Come on man.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Over multiple 90 point seasons and a selke finalist?

Maybe the fact that you have to add the kid’s age after every stat

Also did you seriously just ask what is potential about pacing for 100? Come on man.

How about post your list, instead of complaining about lists.

 

[ColbyChaos]

Habs fans are throat goats with how they talk about Hutson and his head fakes

*DISCLAIMER some folks seem to be confused - this is not a "who is the best player" or "how do you rank the players" it's how would you as a fan do a top 10 draft list if these teams were forced to throw their players into the pool and snake draft new rosters.

Assuming the three Eastern Canada teams in fantasy land entered a re-draft including all active roster NHLers (exg: no Demidov, Yakemchuk, Cowan) how do you think the top 10 would fall? Accounting for age, contract duration/$ amount. This is totally for fun and given the fanbases this is going to go one of two ways lol

As a Habs fan, my top 10 would probably be:

1. Stutzle - if he stops diving he could be a crowd favourite such an excellent player
2. Matthews - contract/wrist scare me but he's the best player on this list AINEC
3. Hutson - ELC + I have watched enough to know he will be in that Hughes/Makar/Josi/Fox tier of production
4. Nylander - Pre-COVID I wanted a Weber/Nylander swap so badly - such an elite player who loves the big moments
5. Caufield - Caufield is nowhere near his final level of development - I expect him to be a mini Marty by his late 20s
6. Tkachuk - A dying breed of power forward pest on a great contract
7. Marner - I still think he's one of the best two-way wingers in the league but expiring contract/big money
8. Guhle/Sanderson (interchangeable - Guhle gives me elite #2 DFD, Sanderson could be a real #1 who runs the show, Guhle better contract)
10. Suzuki - Most underrated forward in the Atlantic IMO (biased opinion but it is what it is)

H.Ms:
Slaf - has not proven enough yet to be more valuable than any of the above
Knies - I suspect he will be a cup winning power forward for an American team with warm weather one day
Batherson - Probably my #11 - think Stutzle/Brady contribute to his point total a lot but a great player in his own right

We really need a clown react for this exact type of post.

 

[Agent Zuuuub]

Over multiple 90 point seasons and a selke finalist?

Maybe the fact that you have to add the kid’s age after every stat

Also did you seriously just ask what is potential about pacing for 100? Come on man.

So I guess you're of the belief that Stutzle has much much higher potential than what he's already accomplished.


You know what I agree with you.

 

[34]

So just to confirm, you step up to the podium at 2OA and with your pick you are drafting Marner with 1 year left on his contract over Stutzle who is locked up for another 6 years after this one?

Marner > Stutzle

 

[Connor McConnor]

Sees thread title. Assumes it will turn into a piss fest.

Confirmed.

 

[Atomos2]

So I guess you're of the belief that Stutzle has much much higher potential than what he's already accomplished.


You know what I agree with you.

Does he have the potential to be Mitch Marner? Sure I guess if he can learn defence.

Anyway, follow the conversation trail. Not once did I acknowledge the guy’s list as my preference, thank god for that…

 

[Golden_Jet]

Marner > Stutzle

What’s your list

Does he have the potential to be Mitch Marner? I guess if he can learn defence.

Anyway, follow the conversation trail. Not once did I acknowledge the guy’s list as a reality.

Still waiting for that list. Maybe you forgot.
lol @ defense. Should watch him, more than the one game Sens dominated the leafs.
Marner +3 on team with +11 goal differential
Stutzle +6 on a +4 goal differential team.

 

[Atomos2]

In the spirit of this thread:
Matthews
Nylander
Marner
Stutzle
Suzuki
Caufield
Tkachuk
Laine
Sanderson
Slafkovsky

 

[Crazy8oooo]

Matthews
Stutzle
Marner
Nylander
Tkachuk
Sanderson
Suzuki
Caufield
Slafkovsky
Batherson

 

[ottawa]

Like every other year, I look forward to reading the Marner thread this summer after the Leafs get eliminated yet again in the 1st/2nd round.

The worst part is, the same Leafs fans that bashed him earlier this summer are probably the same ones here praising him as a God in this thread. You guys have the memory of a goldfish lol

 

[Agent Zuuuub]

Does he have the potential to be Mitch Marner? Sure I guess if he can learn defence.

Anyway, follow the conversation trail. Not once did I acknowledge the guy’s list as my preference, thank god for that…

i'd be pretty disappointed if stutzle potential was only mitch marner tbh.

which isn't bad but stutzle looking special special so far, so marner would be a let down.

 

[The Management]

Like every other year, I look forward to reading the Marner thread this summer after the Leafs get eliminated yet again in the 1st/2nd round.

The worst part is, the same Leafs fans that bashed him earlier this summer are probably the same ones here praising him as a God in this thread. You guys have the memory of a goldfish lol

I think he's just a really polarizing player. It's because he's so good in the regular season that fans get upset when he doesn't have the same presence in the post-season. It's not a memory issue, it's just a hope (misguided or otherwise) that it all "clicks" for him at some point.

 

[SNES]

Over multiple 90 point seasons and a selke finalist?

Maybe the fact that you have to add the kid’s age after every stat

Also did you seriously just ask what is potential about pacing for 100? Come on

In the spirit of this thread:
Matthews
Nylander
Marner
Stutzle
Suzuki
Caufield
Tkachuk
Laine
Sanderson
Slafkovsky

Wooooooof! No wonder no one takes you seriously…yeesh

 

[FerrisRox]

8. Guhle/Sanderson (interchangeable - Guhle gives me elite #2 DFD, Sanderson could be a real #1 who runs the show, Guhle better contract)

This is absolutely absurd. They are not remotely the same thing. Sanderson is twice the defender Guhle is.

Get a clue.

 

[Korpse]

This is absolutely absurd. They are not remotely the same thing. Sanderson is twice the defender Guhle is.

Get a clue.

They called Sanderson an OFD in another post. They think Sanderson is having a brutal year defensively, I'm assuming that's based on +/- where a 4% on ice shooting % is throwing that number to the negative side.