For the life of me I cannot understand why any of these players would get raises like that. NONE of them are worth it. Earn it. Play better and then get paid.
This team needs guys like Kadri sitting out because he wants more money than he should get. He hasn't done anything to merit that money. His play has regressed since he signed his last deal.
Bernier hasn't even been an NHL goalie the last 2 months.
Just got rid of Clarkson -- do not need ANY overpaid players.
Kadri -- 3 million -- one year -- providing he isn't a UFA after.
Panik 1 million
Bernier 3 million one year -- providing he isn't a UFA after.
Holland 1 million -- one year
If they balk -- trade them.
Very short-sighted plan there.
So let's assume we take your advice, sign Kadri for a one-year, $3.5M deal (same as current + inflation).
IF he EARNS it, we'll have burned another year of RFA, and basically will have to be looking at re-signing him as a UFA, where he will command much more leverage in contract negotiations leading to a potential $5.5M or $6M deal.
I assume you would balk at that and not sign him, and somehow magically find better UFAs in free agency willing to sign for well-below market value, based solely on your whim.
There is no way your business model makes sense. You have to pay players market value. The only real leverage teams have is with term and RFA years.
Leafs NEED to re-sign Kadri for 5+ years which is the only way his cap hit will be at or below $5M.
$4.5Mx3 is pretty reasonable, but if the rebuild is going to take 3-5 years, then Kadri would be due for another raise when the rebuild was done, meaning he would ultimately be over-priced by then, unless he proved to be an essential component in the new team design.
Either way, waiting until later to sign him to a good cap hit with term is a colossal mistake, as the opportunity will never present itself again.
At $5Mx5years, if he isn't worth that money, he's still tradeable as that would be reasonable for a 2C/3C if the Leafs take a bad contract in return or eat some salary.
The point is having a cost-controlled Kadri when this rebuild is done. If that's not going to be possible, trade him at the draft now while he's still got RFA years and can get the Leafs a solid return.