You realize this is how it works in other team sports too? "All-time" is either for the regular season OR the playoffs.
Why would you want to count both together when a bunch of players would be disadvantaged because of the teams they played on during their career?
Right, it makes sense on some level, but it is odd how we celebrate 1000 games, 500 goals, etc., but the playoff numbers don’t ever really get any shine until it’s HHOF convo time. Just an example- Selanne was just over ppg over 1451 games (1457 points). “Just” 88 points in 130 playoff games, though, and since we don’t really focus on those numbers we just kinda forget that his style didn’t work in the playoffs as much, or that the numbers aren’t as good at least. We notice stark exceptions, Justin Williams and Joe Thornton, but it’s a bit odd how we largely disregard the stats that get you that cup everyone makes such a big deal out of.
Not really sure what the solution is, just sayin I kinda get OP’s point whilst agreeing with ya that it’s not somethin I’d combine or anything.