How would you grade the Habs drafting from 2017-2021 ?

[montreal]

In 2018 I wanted to trade down if we got another 1st and take Boqvist, now he's on waivers. Looks like I whiffed on that one. Not that I wouldn't mind taking a shot on him for free since he's a young RD.

 

[WeThreeKings]

In 2018 I wanted to trade down if we got another 1st and take Boqvist, now he's on waivers. Looks like I whiffed on that one. Not that I wouldn't mind taking a shot on him for free since he's a young RD.

Yeah I wanted Boqvist over KK.. I wasn't hitting well in that draft. Didn't want Tkachuk, liked Hughes but not as much as Boqvist.

 

[montreal]

Yeah I wanted Boqvist over KK.. I wasn't hitting well in that draft. Didn't want Tkachuk, liked Hughes but not as much as Boqvist.

I was big on Hughes and thought he was more impressive at Michigan then Tkachuk was at BU. Frankly to this day I am still surprised at how good Tkachuk ended up as he just didn't impress at all in the NCAA (not like I was watching him that much though). I did have some concerns over Hughes's lack of size but man was he impressive.

 

[Habs Halifax]

A lot of players that started out well tailed off. Hopefully that won't be the case for Dobes, Kapanen, and Roy...

It happens. The key to this is quantity which helps probability. You get some surprises, some develop as expected, and some fade.

 

[Hins77]

I don't agree. I'd rather have Dach than Romanov. Dach's had injuries that have messed things up a bit but going forward would you really rather have Romanov than Dach?

Dach will need to step up his game and makes around 50/60 points as a real 2nd centerman to make this trade a win for Montreal.
Since Romanov is playings for the Islanders, he is a physical dman playing on the first pairing. Brings a lot of hits, a lot of blocks shots, a positive ratio, and around 25 points/year. Imo, he is the kind of 3rd dman on a contender team while Dach is currently playing as a 3rd line centerman wich is less important to me, than what Romanov brings for the Islanders.

 

[WeThreeKings]

Dach will need to step up his game and makes around 50/60 points as a real 2nd centerman to make this trade a win for Montreal.
Since Romanov is playings for the Islanders, he is a physical dman playing on the first pairing. Brings a lot of hits, a lot of blocks shots, a positive ratio, and around 25 points/year. Imo, he is the kind of 3rd dman on a contender team while Dach is currently playing as a 3rd line centerman wich is less important to me, than what Romanov brings for the Islanders.

Romanov isn't playing above Guhle or Hutson on the Habs. They made the right trade and Dach would've been close to 50 pts in year one without the injuries, and obviously this year has been recovering from the one he suffered last year. So, it was the right trade to make, a great target, the right surplus defender to move.. we just have to hope that with a full year under his belt, a good off-season of training and some confidence, Dach will come back in next year and provide what he was looking to provide already in year 1 of the trade.

 

[Lafleurs Guy]

Dach will need to step up his game and makes around 50/60 points as a real 2nd centerman to make this trade a win for Montreal.

When healthy that’s what he’s done. Solid physical player and can handle 2nd line duties. His only problem has been staying healthy.

Since Romanov is playings for the Islanders, he is a physical dman playing on the first pairing. Brings a lot of hits, a lot of blocks shots, a positive ratio, and around 25 points/year. Imo, he is the kind of 3rd dman on a contender team while Dach is currently playing as a 3rd line centerman wich is less important to me, than what Romanov brings for the Islanders.

I’d rather have Dach but it’s not a slam dunk. Injuries have gotten in the way. Hopefully it’s a win/win for both clubs.

 

[Habs Halifax]

When healthy that’s what he’s done. Solid physical player and can handle 2nd line duties. His only problem has been staying healthy.

I’d rather have Dach but it’s not a slam dunk. Injuries have gotten in the way. Hopefully it’s a win/win for both clubs.

We have to be patient with Dach. It might be false hope or he proves he is the guy he can be. We just don't know and the true Dach will show at age 25+. Stay healthy and we will know a lot more at the end of next season.

Right now, there is no way to justify a big gap between Romanov and Dach.

 

[Habs Halifax]

Dach will need to step up his game and makes around 50/60 points as a real 2nd centerman to make this trade a win for Montreal.
Since Romanov is playings for the Islanders, he is a physical dman playing on the first pairing. Brings a lot of hits, a lot of blocks shots, a positive ratio, and around 25 points/year. Imo, he is the kind of 3rd dman on a contender team while Dach is currently playing as a 3rd line centerman wich is less important to me, than what Romanov brings for the Islanders.

Romanov is a top 4D. He's playing top pairing but that does not mean he is top pairing. Did you know that Romanov's giveaways/60 is worse than Matheson? Matheson is better in both areas... giveaways/60 and takeaways/60. Go figure eh.

 

[The Real Timo]

Romanov isn't playing above Guhle or Hutson on the Habs. They made the right trade and Dach would've been close to 50 pts in year one without the injuries, and obviously this year has been recovering from the one he suffered last year. So, it was the right trade to make, a great target, the right surplus defender to move.. we just have to hope that with a full year under his belt, a good off-season of training and some confidence, Dach will come back in next year and provide what he was looking to provide already in year 1 of the trade.

Romanov needs to come home. I am still pissed Habs traded him away. This was not a good trade. Dach, it feels, won't become that coveted #2 center. Romy can hit and brings it.