How many teams would Thomas Harley be a #1D on?

[DJN21]

You won’t find a single Red Wings fan—or anyone who watches both teams objectively—who would trade Seider for Harley. Their age difference is just four months, and Seider is already the better player. If you're going to argue that Harley is “only going to get better,” then you have to acknowledge the same is true for Seider.

Drop the exaggeration.

well shit....he wrote it all in bold so I'm blindly in......

 

[Hockeyfan200]

This season?

Chi: yes
Ana: yes
Bos: maybe
Car: no
Col: no
Cgy: yes
Buf: no
Cbj: no
Edm: no
Det: maybe
Nj: no
Min: yes
La: maybe
Fla: yes
Nyi: maybe
Nsh: no
Sj: yes
Mtl: maybe
Nyr: no
Stl: maybe
Sea: yes
Ott: no
Phi: yes
Uta: no
Van: no
Tbl: no
Pit: yes
Wpg: no
Vgk: no
Tor: yes
Wsh: no

10/32, so less than a 1/3. If you give him all the maybes, which is not at all clear-cut, it’s 16/32. He’s an average to high end #2 as it stands right now.

He would not be #1 on Minnesota team with spurgeom, Brodin, and Brock faber. wrong

 

[Hockeyfan200]

You’re grasping at straws here. Faber has been absolutely terrible in the playoffs so far in his career. 0 points in 12 games and gets caved in defensively.

Like I said, the BS narrative that the haters said would happen to Hutson in the playoffs is actually happening to Faber, yet somehow Faber has the reputation of a top Dman to the point that people are in here arguing that Faber is somehow as good as or better than Harley.

Faber was the worst “#1D” in the playoffs, hands down.

You don't judge a player , especially Dman of Point. You're embarrasing yourself. wild wouldn't trading Brodin, Spurgeon or Faber for him. So no he wouldn't

 

[Dotter]

well shit....he wrote it all in bold so I'm blindly in......

Blame the new forum glitching.

 

[Garbageyuk]

He would not be #1 on Minnesota team with spurgeom, Brodin, and Brock faber. wrong

He’s better than all three. Yes, he would be their #1D.

 

[Garbageyuk]

You don't judge a player , especially Dman of Point. You're embarrasing yourself. wild wouldn't trading Brodin, Spurgeon or Faber for him. So no he wouldn't

Well, unfortunately for your narrative, I’m not doing that. I’m judging him off of seeing him play, his possession metrics, his analytics, and yes, his points. Points will always be part of the equation. Harley does absolutely everything better than Faber. If you don’t think that’s true, then explain to me what Faber is better at. So far, everyone who’s taken issue with my take on Faber has not been able to tell why and how he’s as good or better than Harley.

 

[ScottishCanuck]

You called Faber an ‘offensive defenseman’

lol.

What did you expect?

You’re conversing with a guy who thinks the username “garbageyuk” is witty.

 

[Garbageyuk]

What did you expect?

You’re conversing with a guy who thinks the username “garbageyuk” is witty.

Where did you get the idea that it’s supposed to be witty? You’re so pissed lol. Be mad at Faber for being trash, not at me.

 

[Hockeyfan200]

Well, unfortunately for your narrative, I’m not doing that. I’m judging him off of seeing him play, his possession metrics, his analytics, and yes, his points. Points will always be part of the equation. Harley does absolutely everything better than Faber. If you don’t think that’s true, then explain to me what Faber is better at. So far, everyone who’s taken issue with my take on Faber has not been able to tell why and how he’s as good or better than Harley.

You going to take a player who was a stud in his 1st year and injured and playing after the world game things and judge him?? so freaking laughable in every way dude. You said Thomas Harley would be #1 in MN and was called out on your bullcrap. No the f*** he wouldn't. Jonas Brodin is still one of the best shutdown Dman in the NHL Today. Spurgeon was a stud all year. People who try to use point to say a player whose a Dman isn't good tell on themselves

 

[Garbageyuk]

You going to take a player who was a stud in his 1st year and injured and playing after the world game things and judge him?? so freaking laughable in every way dude. You said Thomas Harley would be #1 in MN and was called out on your bullcrap. No the f*** he wouldn't. Jonas Brodin is still one of the best shutdown Dman in the NHL Today. Spurgeon was a stud all year. People who try to use point to say a player whose a Dman isn't good tell on themselves

Again, who said it’s just about points? You, because you need a strawman argument to tear down. That’s all you’ve got. Harley is better than Faber in every way.

 

[Hockeyfan200]

He’s better than all three. Yes, he would be their #1D.

No, the f*** he wouldn't. Again, anyone with a Brain would know he wouldn't. Good luck with that. No player will ever replace Brodin, Spurgeon and Brock Faber in MN or supplement them. You said he would be #1 as if Minnesota doesn't have any Good Dman or two Amazing Dman still in Spurgeon and Brodin along with Faber who even though he struggled in 2nd half of the season was still a stud in the playoff. Even analysts would talk about how good he was.

 

[Fatass]

This season?

Chi: yes
Ana: yes
Bos: maybe
Car: no
Col: no
Cgy: yes
Buf: no
Cbj: no
Edm: no
Det: maybe
Nj: no
Min: yes
La: maybe
Fla: yes
Nyi: maybe
Nsh: no
Sj: yes
Mtl: maybe
Nyr: no
Stl: maybe
Sea: yes
Ott: no
Phi: yes
Uta: no
Van: no
Tbl: no
Pit: yes
Wpg: no
Vgk: no
Tor: yes
Wsh: no

10/32, so less than a 1/3. If you give him all the maybes, which is not at all clear-cut, it’s 16/32. He’s an average to high end #2 as it stands right now.

I agree Harley is really good. And he’d be the top D man on a lot of nhl clubs. But one of those clubs is definitely NOT Boston. McAvoy is one hell of a player.

 

[Hockeyfan200]

Where did you get the idea that it’s supposed to be witty? You’re so pissed lol. Be mad at Faber for being trash, not at me.

anD You're freaking telling on yourself with these Garbage comment

 

[Garbageyuk]

No, the f*** he wouldn't. Again, anyone with a Brain would know he wouldn't. Good luck with that. No player will ever replace Brodin, Spurgeon and Brock Faber in MN or supplement them. You said he would be #1 as if Minnesota doesn't have any Good Dman or two Amazing Dman still in Spurgeon and Brodin along with Faber who even though he struggled in 2nd half of the season was still a stud in the playoff. Even analysts would talk about how good he was.

Yes, he would. Harley is simply better than any D that MIN has. Cry about it if you want to though.

 

[Garbageyuk]

anD You're freaking telling on yourself with these Garbage comment

Lol, you have no counter argument other than crying and whining.

 

[Garbageyuk]

I agree Harley is really good. And he’d be the top D man on a lot of nhl clubs. But one of those clubs is definitely NOT Boston. McAvoy is one hell of a player.

Didn’t say he would be.

 

[Hockeyfan200]

Lol, you have no counter argument other than crying and whining.

You're the one who's being a prik and crying on here. Calling a player garbage because they are on a rival of your team speaks volume about you. You're opinion doesn't mean jack squat dude. Everyone has said you're wrong, and your pride and ego can't take it.

 

[Hockeyfan200]

Yes, he would. Harley is simply better than any D that MIN has. Cry about it if you want to though.

No, the f*** he wouldn't. Again, Dude goes cry elsewhere. You're a Prik whose little ego has been hurt. You don't know shit about wild. You're a joke. No, Thomas H isn't better than Brodin, Spurgeon and Brock. Thomas would be 4th d at best on MN. Go Cry elsewhere

 

[Garbageyuk]

You're the one who's being a prik and crying on here. Calling a player garbage because they are on a rival of your team speaks volume about you. You're opinion doesn't mean jack squat dude. Everyone has said you're wrong, and your pride and ego can't take it.

Yet, you can’t articulate how I’m wrong, and you haven’t backed up your position with anything other than whining. Staying and defending my opinion isn’t being a “prik” lmao. That’s what these boards are for. Take a hike if you can’t handle it.

 

[Fatass]

Didn’t say he would be.

How about going out on a limb and actually listing the clubs you believe Harley would be better than what that team currently has then? I’m seeing a good player in Harley, but a guy who is a #3. Please list the clubs he’d be the 1.

 

[Garbageyuk]

No, the f*** he wouldn't. Again, Dude goes cry elsewhere. You're a Prik whose little ego has been hurt. You don't know shit about wild. You're a joke. No, Thomas H isn't better than Brodin, Spurgeon and Brock. Thomas would be 4th d at best on MN. Go Cry elsewhere

Lmfao you’re losing it, full on meltdown . All I did was state and defend my opinion lmao.

 

[Hockeyfan200]

Yet, you can’t articulate how I’m wrong, and you haven’t backed up your position with anything other than whining. Staying and defending my opinion isn’t being a “prik” lmao. That’s what these boards are for. Take a hike if you can’t handle it.

You keep sayin the same shit to everyone who called you out on your bullcrap and lie. Again dude, Your opinion doesn't mean shit to anyone at all.

 

[Garbageyuk]

How about going out on a limb and actually listing the clubs you believe Harley would be better than what that team currently has then? I’m seeing a good player in Harley, but a guy who is a #3. Please list the clubs he’d be the 1.

Didn’t I do exactly that in the post you originally quoted?

 

[Hockeyfan200]

How about going out on a limb and actually listing the clubs you believe Harley would be better than what that team currently has then? I’m seeing a good player in Harley, but a guy who is a #3. Please list the clubs he’d be the 1.

right? and then he gets mad when called out

 

[Garbageyuk]

You keep sayin the same shit to everyone who called you out on your bullcrap and lie. Again dude, Your opinion doesn't mean shit to anyone at all.

It’s means enough for you to throw a tantrum and quote me over and over crying because I don’t agree with you.