Thought it would be fun to see how some of the draft classes are faring at the start of the 2031-32 season as well! So I'll do a little mini-breakdown of each class from 2023-2029 (the roster right now extends out to a few real 2029 prospects but that's about as young as it gets - and even that of course is doing a heck of a lot of "projecting".
In the fall of 2031, the ages of most of these draft classes would be:
2023: 26 y/o - most of these guys outside of the goalies are done truly developing (keep in mind - ratings can still go up/down at 26 or later for good performances)
2024: 25 y/o
2025: 24 y/o
2026: 23 y/o
2027: 22 y/o
2028: 21 y/o
2029: 20 y/o - most of these guys are truly still unfinished prospects
Keep in mind when you see the "star" ratings - these are not their original potential/motivations at draft time but what they have developed or recessed into over the years of the sim.
2023 TOP 40
- Connor Bedard developed into the real deal, the current #2 center in the game, with Leo Carlsson and Matvei Michkov also franchise-level players and a lot of other top line guys like Adam Fantilli, Will Smith and Ryan Leoanrd all living up to their star prospect billing in this sim.
Only really dud in the Top 10 in this sim was David Reinbacher. Tom Willander also a mild disappointment despite being coded into the roster with a "high" motivation. The biggest high end bombs were Colby Barlow and Eduard Sale. And a big, fat OOF for Charlie Stramel, now plying his trade in Sweden.
Further down in the 20-40 range, Gabe Perreault stands out as a superstar despite his #23 selection - he even pips his higher selected former BC Eagles linemates in rating with a 90 (to the 89 for Smith and Leonard). The guy has 4 straight 100+ point seasons for the Rangers as the spiritual successor to Artemi Panarin. The '23 draft proving its depth years later with lots of "hits" in this range.
Best pick outside the Top 40 (non-goalie):
Beau Akey, #56 Overall, EDM - Plenty of good choices but let's go with Akey, a smooth-skating two-way defender who has blossomed into a solid top four rearguard for the Oilers, with a career high 50-point season under his belt.
Best pick after #150 (non-goalie):
Daniil Karpovich, #186 Overall, NJD - The Belorussian defender, now with Edmonton, made an immediate impact after coming over from the KHL.
Best Goalie:
Trey Augustine, #41 Overall, DET - Lots of good choices with guys like Clara and Gajan also exploding but none as much as the former NCAA standout, now with New Jersey, who appears to be the guy going forward in net for Team USA.
2024 TOP 40
- Mack Celebrini did not quite get to generational level but developed into every bit the excellent first overall franchise pick. Artyom Levshunov, Cayden Lindstrom and Berkley Catton also really exploded this time around into superstars. No real duds in the top 10 with Bennett Sennecke and Carter Yakemchuk at least being middle of the line-up options while Tij Iginla, Zayne Parekh and Jett Luchanko also developing into stars.
Biggest top pick bust was Zeev Buium, who has yet to become an NHL regular after staying all fours year at Denver. Further down in the 1st, Trevor Connelly, Cole Eiserman, Matvei Gridin and Emil Hemming have been underwhelming and lost tons of stars. Some sims you strike gold, others you strike out!
In the 20-40 range, the busts about equal the breakouts but you'll get no complaints on the development of the likes of Michael Hage, Yegor Surin, Lucas Pettersson and Ilya Nabokov, who have all turned into top level players.
Best pick outside the Top 40 (non-goalie):
Nikita Artamonov, #50 Overall, CAR - Looking like a potential steal of the draft in real life as he lights up the KHL and no different in this sim as he's been a reliable 70-80 playmaking star for the Canes.
Best pick after #150 (non-goalie):
Antoine Dorion, #209 Overall, STL - Making the Maple Leafs as a now 25 year-old rookie, Dorion's path has been long and winding but he's suddenly blossomed into an NHL talent.
Best Goalie:
Mikhail Yegorov, #49, NJD - Yegorov took a while to get going after playing the NCAA and AHL but now in Utah, he's exploded into a really good starter. Just another top level Russian goalie, nothing to see here...
2025 TOP 40
- The first draft class you'll get a shot at drafting in HLM25 and now entering their age 23/24 seasons, the first thing you notice is the top 5 in this sim really came through. James Hagens really did develop into a superstar franchise player, but he's joined at hat elite level by Porter Martone and Anton Frondell. Michael Misa and Vitkor Eklund linger not far off that pace, while the raw but imposing Logan Hensler proving an astute, if surprising, choice by San Jose as the first defender off the board over Matt Schaefer.
Busts? Probably too early to write-off anybody completely yet...but...Ivan Ryabkin...we need to have a discussion. Despite a 4.5 Star Potential and Yellow/Medium motivation, Ryabkin seemed a great choice by Philly to pair as his compatriot, Michkov's, long-term center. Things...have not gone well. He will be lucky to salvage any kind of NHL career, down to 3 stars and stuck in the AHL. Further down the 1st, Swedish and BU defender Sascha Boumedienne has now dropped to a 2-star potential and will be back in Europe soon.
Early steals in the 20-40 range include WHL standout defensive prospect Will Sharpe and current USNTDP member and future BC Eagle WIll Moore, whose drop to the end of the 1st mimics his real life fall in reputation - but he looks to be making the most of his potential in this sim.
Despite almost 500 draft - eligible real prospects for 2025 (including overagers) in this roster, the CPU snuck a couple generated guys into the top of this draft ("Chavez" and "Potvin") - but you'll still be able to feel the realism at every pick in all 7 rounds.
Best pick outside the Top 40 (non-goalie):
Jacob Rombach, #71 Overall, PIT - The lanky defender is an intriguing prospect in real-life and has come through in this sim as a towering, no-nonsense top-4 blueliner for the Penguins after some standout seasons for the Gophers in the NCAA.
Best pick after #150 (non-goalie):
Dovydas Jukna, #157 Overall, WPG - Our Lithuanian savior has arrived! The power winger prospect who is currently developing in Switzerland, has turned into a middle-six gem for the Jets.
Best Goalie:
Semyon Frolov, #89 Overall, SJS - Ho-hum another star Russian goalie - and it's not even the guy you may be thinking from this crop (Pytor Andreyanov). Except that San Jose already had another Russian in net, Yaroslav Askarov, so they deal Frolov to Montral this off-season where he looks to lock-down the #1 spot at age 24.
2026 TOP 40
- Well, just call this the "McKenna" draft as the WHL prodigy has surpassed everybody in this sim to become the next generational forward. OHL power forward product Ethan Belchetz and Swedish center Viggo Bjorck also have already developed into franchise players from the top 10 while in the middle of the 1st, another steal for Carolina with Swedish superstar winger Ivar Stenberg. Speedy winger J.P. Hurlbut and rugged two-way defender Keaton Verhoff also developing into stars early on.
Most of these guys are still around 23 and so still have development runway but at this point, 4th overall Czech power forward Simon Katolicky has not lived up to his billing and there are some guys further down the list already bleeding stars...for example Tomas Chrenko at #37 and Chase Harrington at #39 have already dropped to 2 stars, essentially establishing their bust status.
Some steals int he 20-40 range look to be Russian winger Alexei Vlasov at #23 to Buffalo, Latvian center Olivers Murnieks at #26 to Calgary while pick #40 is Manny Malhotra's son, Caleb, who has been trending really well.
The CPU has snuck a few top-level prospects into this group as computer generated (3 in the top 40 - "Vesel", "Gustafsson' and "Richardson") but again you will find the entire crop thick with real-life prospects, more than enough that with some overagers from previous drafts, Mr. Irrelevant this time around, Edison Engle at #224, is still very much a real prospect.
Best pick outside the Top 40 (non-goalie):
Cole Bumgarner, #69 Overall, LAK - The powerful winger from Minnesota took the USHL to NCAA to NHL path and is coming off a 29 goal, 68-point breakout season for the Kings.
Best pick after #150 (non-goalie):
Ethan Garden, #170 Overall, ANA - Like Bumgarner, he was passed up by the USNTDP but he ended up an OHL star and 6th round pick by the Ducks where he's already a bottom-six fixture.
Best Goalie:
William Lacelle, #73 Overall, OTT - Still early to judge goalies but QMJHL product Lacelle was tossed into the fire as a 61-game starter for Ottawa last year at age 22 and aims to make it his net his for a long time.
2027 TOP 40
- Two words: Landon. Freaking. Dupont. If you are managing a tanking team in HLM, you might want to keep tanking through the 26/27 season so you have a shot at this potentially generational defenseman. He's lighting it up in real life in the WHL and he more than lives up to the billing this time, At age 22, he has a 96 rating, has never been below a PPG in the NHL and has 3 90+ point seasons under his belt.
This draft has proven interesting thus far with another Canadian phenom, James Scantlebury, slightly underwhelming so far. But several guys have turned into young franchise players...German Max Penkin, future NCAA star Rocco Pelosi and big Swedish center Dorain Eklund-Aspe.
Even in 2027, you'll see almost all real prospects, at least early in the draft. Only 1 of the top 40 is a CPU-generated player, "Kline". Deeper in the draft you'll start getting a few more CPU players mixed in but even in the 7th round, there are some good, real prospects you can nab as overagers.
Best pick outside the Top 40 (non-goalie):
Milan Sundstrom, #47 Overall, BUF - Still very early but let's go with the big, feisty and versatile Swede - who is the son of former two-way NHLer Niklas Sunstrom. Milan is like a much bigger, souped-up version of his dad and already an NHL regular, now with Vegas.
Best pick after #150 (non-goalie):
Jonas Lagerberg Hoen, #206 Overall, LAK - An overager, Lagerberg Hoen is a two-way winger who is breaking camp as an NHL rookie with Carolina this fall.
Best Goalie:
Alessandro Do Monte, #96, DAL - Traded to the Avs organization, Do Monte was a QMJHL (eligible for next summer's Q draft in real life as an '09) product who looks to have won the Avs backup job this fall as a 22-year-old rookie.
2028 TOP 40
- 2028 is the first draft year (these are 2010 and late 2009 borns) that you will start to feel more of an impact of CPU-generated prospects, simply because the number of real prospects (kids) that have actual scouting reports and info available starts to drop off at this age group. And when I add prospects to the HLMX roster - it is never just "insert random list of players from an Eliteprospects list"...I only really do it if there is actual info on the player available - and I will rate such young phenoms in way that will at least give them a very, very good shot at being relevant in the sim.
That said, you'll still find a heady amount of top real-life prospects in this draft class. The top 3 picks, for example - Liam Pue, Maddox Schultz and Will LoSauro - are all very much guys with some level of hype in real life. Same with other top picks like Charlie Leonard, Milo Spelkvist and Daniil Pavlenin. Looking at this Top 40, a bit more than half are real and a bit less are CPU-generated. Later rounds will be more CPU-generated for this class at this point, though as the real 24-25 season progresses, I anticipate I'll be adding considerably to this age group with real players.
2029 TOP 20
- 2029 is the final draft class featuring real players at the moment - and as of the moment of this post, about a dozen guys who are notable potential phenoms or prodigious youth players. That includes names like Tyson Orr, Dominik Zelezny, Juho Nyberg, Max Melicherik, Julian Donatsch and Oliver Tomastik - all picked in the Top 10 of the 2029 draft in this sim.