Tenants with a Room was the greatest thing lol. I still don't even know where I got the inspiration for the monkey from, but it was an amazingly different dynamic from everything else on the show, especially The Outcasts vs. Rushmore and HFWF rivalry, and the best part was that you KNEW when the tone shifted in that rivalry when the fun and games ended and ColePens and Disclose tried to murder each other.The booking is also closer to a more realistic wrestling setting like ROH or NJPW. NXT might be the closest. Not main roster WWE though. The booking doesn’t have as much room for Super over the top gimmicks that some of our WWE counter parts had at their peaks.
Not to say there isn’t some bollocks and silliness, but this product overall is much more grounded. Which is a good thing. I think that is where the best of modern wrestling is right now.
I don't like going SO far off the deep end with campy stuff, but there's a time and a place for it and I think if this were real life, it was the perfect time to introduce the campy stuff to really get TWR over, and it was the perfect time to end the fun and games to shift the change of mood in the rivalry into somewhere more personal and darker.
NXT and NJPW are definitely more inspirations for this style of product, from the in-ring product, to the subtle changes and tones in character stuff that just adds on to someone's character rather than replacing a trait. The characters don't change (and the ones that do have a hard time escaping their past, like Disclose), but the characters just get different traits, some taking over others more, and what those characters go through shapes them moving forward into the direction they take.
Would Disclose become what he has if he had beaten ColePens in the unsanctioned match? Probably not. Would ColePens have become champ if he lost? Probably not. Would ColePens have had that rude awakening at how good the talent in the HFWF is now and that he needs to utilize whatever he can to get what he wants if he lost? Definitely not, his character wouldn't be able to show its face after that loss.