GDT: HFBoards GDT: 03/05/2023 | 5 Games

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
Status
Not open for further replies.
And the Hawks get two goals from missed icing call.

How

F***ing

Typical

i don’t mind the no icing call, when a defender steps up and takes away a players stick on a pass and chip it shouldn’t be icing but they are too inconsistent on that play.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: Summer Rose
Soderblom is dog crap. the whole point of being 6'3" you moron is to stand tall in the net so the puck doesn't go over you.

i don’t mind the no icing call, when a defender steps up and takes away a players stick on a pass and chip it shouldn’t be icing but they are too inconsistent on that play.
They are consistent. Everything is icing if it goes the distance even if as player just stands there and watches the puck go by.
 
Tyler bertuzzi is one squirrelly lookin mf
quirrel.jpg
 
i don’t mind the no icing call, when a defender steps up and takes away a players stick on a pass and chip it shouldn’t be icing but they are too inconsistent on that play.
This is the thing. Total inconsistency.

Alsonwould be nice if referees could try to avoid doing picks on teams in the offensive zone. GET OUT OF THE WAY FOR EFF's SAKE.
 
i don’t mind the no icing call, when a defender steps up and takes away a players stick on a pass and chip it shouldn’t be icing but they are too inconsistent on that play.

I agree with this, but it's one of the few grey areas were linesmen get to make a judgment call and determine whether the defending player had the opportunity to play the puck with "ordinary effort" and chose to play the stick or body instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Korpse
I agree with this, but it's one of the few grey areas were linesmen get to make a judgment call and determine whether the defending player had the opportunity to play the puck with "ordinary effort" and chose to play the stick or body instead.
They don't do that though, Anything that gets down the ice is 99% of the time icing regardless of how stupid the call is.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Neil Racki
They don't do that though, Anything that gets down the ice is 99% of the time icing regardless of how stupid the call is.

Well, yes, I would say that about 99% of the time that a team causes the puck to go from their own side of the red line all the way down across the goal line, it's icing, so it's not exactly a common occurrence that a linesman has to make a judgment call about whether he thinks a defending player had the opportunity to play the puck with ordinary effort before it crosses the goal line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Neil Racki
Saw the Caps' John Carlson put a big hit on NY's Matt Rempe and thought, "Man Carlson's gotta be brave going at a big sasquatch like Rempe"

But then again, Carlson, known more for his finesse play, is a 6'3 230 pound man himself. Not exactly small potatoes.
Rempe had to feel that one...ouch...
 
Well, yes, I would say that about 99% of the time that a team causes the puck to go from their own side of the red line all the way down across the goal line, it's icing, so it's not exactly a common occurrence that a linesman has to make a judgment call about whether he thinks a defending player had the opportunity to play the puck with ordinary effort before it crosses the goal line.
When a defenseman is right along the boards at the point and puck goes right along the boards past him they should just let the play continue,
 
  • Like
Reactions: Summer Rose
Eh. I think the icing rule is fine as it is. While it does have the occasional judgment call built into it, it's simply a rule and you play the game accordingly to it.
There are FAR too many icings. Never used to be that many. Maybe thice is better and faster than years ago or the players are incapable of putting touch on the puck to avoid icing.

Mantinpalo won't want to see the tape of that. Sens did have numbers though.. decided to cover no one.
Marron deked the defenseman effed up the scoring chance but managed to set up Smith.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad