HF GM Games Fantasy Mock Draft #3 - Discussion III

[Paralyzer008]

Doesn’t really matter now but yes. Meier is a top line talent and now you have a 2nd line of tweeners and third liners.

Tatar was a better player than Meier this year, my concern about the trade was name cred would go to Meier.

 

[Panda Bear]

This year doesn’t mean much when he was barely a 4th liner last year.

Last year when he was in Montreal the full season?

 

[Panda Bear]

Tatar was a better player than Meier this year, my concern about the trade was name cred would go to Meier.

Yeah, but I'm 20 PandaPoints happier now.

 

[Exquisite]

This year doesn’t mean much when he was barely a 4th liner last year.

Makes sense now why you have the most beef with me

Tatar is fantastic

 

[LT]

This year doesn’t mean much when he was barely a 4th liner last year.

Barely a 4th liner but put up 25 goals and 60 points???

 

[Gecklund]

Last year when he was in Montreal the full season?

He’s a tweener and Meier is 7x the player Tatar is. Doesn’t really matter now that you gave up Meier. Went from middle of the back to rock bottom with one move.

obviously I meant with Vegas.

 

[Exquisite]

Before Panda gets too happy, Meier is a better fit for his team and equated to more votes

 

[Exquisite]

He’s a tweener and Meier is 7x the player Tatar is. Doesn’t really matter now that you gave up Meier. Went from middle of the back to rock bottom with one move.

obviously I meant with Vegas.

Rofl 7x

On some teams Tatar is better than Meier

 

[Panda Bear]

Before Panda gets too happy, Meier is a better fit for his team and equated to more votes

Maybe, but I'm pretty chill.

Guentzel-McDavid-Coleman
Tatar-Soderberg-Palmieri

>>>

Guentzel-McDavid-Palmieri
Coleman-Soderberg-Meier

 

[Peter Griffin]

Confirm Tatar/Meier swap.

Personally I think it's pretty even, they were even selected within a handful of picks in this draft. I've just had a change of heart and prefer a more physical winger more capable of playing RW.

 

[LT]

He’s a tweener and Meier is 7x the player Tatar is. Doesn’t really matter now that you gave up Meier. Went from middle of the back to rock bottom with one move.

obviously I meant with Vegas.

He didn't fit well with Vegas. For like 20 games.

He's been a top 6 player for the last 6 years outside of that short stint (in an already loaded top 6).

 

[Gecklund]

Rofl 7x

On some teams Tatar is better than Meier

Yeah on teams where he’d be with Giroux and Barzal, not with Coleman and Soderberg. Tatar is a third wheel, Meier is a play driver.

 

[Exquisite]

Confirm Tatar/Meier swap.

Personally I think it's pretty even, they were even selected within a hanful of picks in this draft. I've just had a change of heart and prefer a more physical winger more capable of playing RW.

Glad ppl care about correct positions

 

[hockeynorth]

So clearly I don't know how to evaluate centres, not surprising. At least I have a dozen targets I like for my next pick... oh right I traded that... oh right I can't trade anymore to get it back... uh oh 50 picks to wait

 

[Exquisite]

He didn't fit well with Vegas. For like 20 games.

He's been a top 6 player for the last 6 years outside of that short stint (in an already loaded top 6).

Meier played with play drivers and shot generating players on SJ

 

[Panda Bear]

Yeah on teams where he’d be with Giroux and Barzal, not with Coleman and Soderberg. Tatar is a third wheel, Meier is a play driver.

hahahahahahahaha at Tatar as a third wheel

 

[LT]

Meier played with play drivers and shot generating players on SJ

I think you quoted the wrong post

 

[Gecklund]

Meier played with play drivers and shot generating players on SJ

Man I watched every Sharks game. That’s just not true.

 

[LT]

Who'd have thought the most even trade all game would cause so much controversy

 

[hockeynorth]

My opinion, I prefer Meier to Tatar stylistically, BUT, they're both pretty even production wise and a wash in my opinion. Had them ranked close together.

 

[Exquisite]

So clearly I don't know how to evaluate centres, not surprising. At least I have a dozen targets I like for my next pick... oh right I traded that... oh right I can't trade anymore to get it back... uh oh 50 picks to wait

I would really move down my upcoming picks if I could.. latvian.. please

 

[Paralyzer008]

Maybe, but I'm pretty chill.

Guentzel-McDavid-Coleman
Tatar-Soderberg-Palmieri

>>>

Guentzel-McDavid-Palmieri
Coleman-Soderberg-Meier

Guentzel-McDavid-Coleman
Tatar-Soderberg-Palmieri

OR

Zucker-McDavid-Palmieri
Gaudreau-Staal-Armia

 

[hockeynorth]

Who'd have thought the most even trade all game would cause so much controversy

Trade debates make me happy

 

[Peter Griffin]

@SJSharks39 now that I have Meier, trade me Giroux for him.

 

[Gecklund]

Who'd have thought the most even trade all game would cause so much controversy

All the trades suck. This one just sucks with a player that I have paid attention to for years and happened when I’m not at work.

@SJSharks39 now that I have Meier, trade me Giroux for him.

If not for name value f*** yeah I would