Early in the season, the big reason Berard looked better, is because he got a lot of his points at 5v5 and Othmann had a bad plus-minus because he was always on the ice with the goalie pulled (6v5) leading to a minus a lot.
However, the last 2 months it has evened out a bit with Othmann scoring more 5v5.
I still think Berard is the more impressive rookie in Hartford this season, but his upside may be limited. I could easily see both make the team out of camp in September.
I don't think Berard's upside is limited. He's flying out there, great speed and terrific hockey sense. Sees the ice well, fearless. If you compare him to the borderline NHLers on the roster (Nash, Leschyshyn, Blidh, Petan), he looks easily better than them.
At this point, I'd pencil him in as a Rangers forward to start the season in October. If he doesn't make it, there is always a trade that can be made by giving up a 2-4 rounder for a bottom-6 player later in the 2024-25 season, but I wouldn't waste cap space or picks to get someone more experienced to start the season.
I think he starts as a simple game, energy player, which is how Kreider started around the same age. Obviously Kreider is a different player given his size, but the point is that Berard can start as an energy player and progress to something much more by his mid-20s. I think he has very realistic top-6 potential.