Ogopogo*
Guest
Someone requested my ratings for players like Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor and Tom Dunderdale from the early major pro hockey leagues on par with the NHL. Here are the top 10 from each of the 3 leagues:
PCHA Scoring Leaders (1912-1924)
1 Fred "Cyclone" Taylor
2 Tom Dunderdale
3 Bernie Morris
4 Frank Foyston
5 Duncan "Mickey" MacKay
6 Frank Fredrickson
7 Wilfred "Smokey" Harris
8 Eddie Oatman
9 Gord Roberts
10 Jack Adams
WCHL Scoring Leaders (1923-1926)
1 Bill Cook
2 Gordon "Duke" Keats
3 Harry Oliver
4 George Hay
5 Art Gagne
6 Dick Irvin
7 Duncan MacKay
8 Corb Denneny
9 Edouard "Newsy" Lalonde
10 Barney Stanley
Frank Fredrickson
NHA Scoring Leaders (1910-1917)
1 Joe Malone
2 Didier Pitre
Tommy Smith
4 Newsy Lalonde
5 Harry Hyland
6 Gord Roberts
7 Ernie Russell
Frank Nighbor
Odie Cleghorn
10 Albert Kerr
PCHA Scoring Leaders (1912-1924)
1 Fred "Cyclone" Taylor
2 Tom Dunderdale
3 Bernie Morris
4 Frank Foyston
5 Duncan "Mickey" MacKay
6 Frank Fredrickson
7 Wilfred "Smokey" Harris
8 Eddie Oatman
9 Gord Roberts
10 Jack Adams
WCHL Scoring Leaders (1923-1926)
1 Bill Cook
2 Gordon "Duke" Keats
3 Harry Oliver
4 George Hay
5 Art Gagne
6 Dick Irvin
7 Duncan MacKay
8 Corb Denneny
9 Edouard "Newsy" Lalonde
10 Barney Stanley
Frank Fredrickson
NHA Scoring Leaders (1910-1917)
1 Joe Malone
2 Didier Pitre
Tommy Smith
4 Newsy Lalonde
5 Harry Hyland
6 Gord Roberts
7 Ernie Russell
Frank Nighbor
Odie Cleghorn
10 Albert Kerr