Toggle sidebar

Gordie Clark

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
hightide85 said:
I HATE this..

We have NO idea how these guys will do. How can we say we've done pretty well??

We can't. So annoying. Enough already.
Click to expand...


A realistic expectation for anyone taken in the second round is at best 2nd liner, average 3rd liner and below average 4th liner or bust. Looking at most of our 2 rd picks or later that have played in the NHL, we've had a few misses but Cally, Dubi, and Anisimov are either average or above average (hell, Callys wearing the A and Dubi was centering the 1st line last year).

While we cant look with 100% certainty tha tthese guys will pan out the same, id say you can go by our history and say these guys will at the very least be excellent rolepayers on the team for years to come. If one of them turns into a 2nd or 1st liner, bonus to us.
 
Always happy to see Gordie.. now go to work and do your thing. Not that impressed the last few years, but on the other hand, what players did we realisticly pass on?

Btw, is it true that he runs the table at draft days while other teams have their GM doing the same?
 
AlwaysARanger said:
Always happy to see Gordie.. now go to work and do your thing. Not that impressed the last few years, but on the other hand, what players did we realisticly pass on?

Btw, is it true that he runs the table at draft days while other teams have their GM doing the same?
Click to expand...

How about Taraseko and Saad?
 
Inferno said:
its always a great idea to bump 4 year old threads.


always.
Click to expand...

Don't really see the problem with it. There should probably be a thread for him. With all the appreciation threads after each game why not?

In today's day and age you need youth constantly banging at the door and being infused into the lineup and since Clark has taken over this team has been able to do that. He's a huge reason for our success.
 
The Rangers have struck gold with picks after the 1st round.

Clark has something to do with that. A lot, actually.

Rangers scouts have been outstanding.
 
valence said:
I been watching NYR drafts a long time and I always see this gentlemen going up the podium every year.
The draft analysts(announcers) seems to like him cause they make it seem like he is a good judge of talent. I believe he is the director of player personnel for the rangers for how long?...i don't know BUT shouldn't he be part of the rangers history of "bad" drafts.
Correct me pls but the draft success of the rangers is below average at best and i know that Mr. Sather has a lot of to do with it along with other prior ranger gms.
Is Mr. Clarke any good or is it time for him to go along with Sather's present crew.
Click to expand...


It's a matter of opinion but most folks here don't really understand what that means. There are obviously a LOT of reasons to disagree with your opinions but there are valid reasons to feel the way you do too. I prefer to look at how many drafted players succeed on average, how many top notch offensive players are actually available at the spots the NYR picked at, and the overall ability to draft for players who contribute in meaningful ways. I also lend weight to prospect trades since the reason why a team targets let's say McD in a trade is b/c the prospect staff scouted him out.
 
GWOW said:
The Rangers have struck gold with picks after the 1st round.

Clark has something to do with that. A lot, actually.

Rangers scouts have been outstanding.
Click to expand...

Agree.

I trust Clark.
 
taking a look at the roster going into the 14-15 season we see

Stepan
Hagelin
Fast
Kreider
Staal
Henrik as draft picks

Girardi was signed as a free agent

with the exception of Fast that is 6 very solid NHL players. Not bad drafting/scouting I would say.
 
I'm sorry but I find Clark's drafting to be overrated. 2008, 2010 were terrible picks. Sure he's found a few nice later picks but as far as drafting first line talent, well there's a reason why we always try to sign or trade for the big names.
 
Glen Teflon Sather said:
I'm sorry but I find Clark's drafting to be overrated. 2008, 2010 were terrible picks. Sure he's found a few nice later picks but as far as drafting first line talent, well there's a reason why we always try to sign or trade for the big names.
Click to expand...

How many first rounders make the NHL?

Kreider. Stepan. They signed MZA.
 
NYR Viper said:
How many first rounders make the NHL?

Kreider. Stepan. They signed MZA.
Click to expand...

Stepan was a 2nd.

Miller (probably making the team)
Kreider
DZ
Staal

Are all NHL players drafted in the 1st by the rangers. Not that impressive but we've made up for it in later rounds and undrafted UFA signings
 
So basically we're mad at Clark for not striking gold and drafting a Getzlaf in the late first round
 
Dactyl said:
Stepan was a 2nd.

Miller (probably making the team)
Kreider
DZ
Staal

Are all NHL players drafted in the 1st by the rangers. Not that impressive but we've made up for it in later rounds and undrafted UFA signings
Click to expand...

Not that impressive? Cheraponov passed away. That's not on Clark.

Miller
Skjei
McIlrath

All look to be well on their way to be NHL players. I ask again, what is the percentage of 1st rounders that make the NHL. Who have been the busts? Sanguinetti? That's it up to this point.
 
The problem with the Rangers prospect pool and draft record isn't on Clark per se. Sather has traded away too many firsts and picks in general. It's like he finally comprehended how to build a team in the salary cap era and then he didn't.

Looking at Football, I know it's a bit different, but you can still draw parallels. The most inane thing a GM can do in the salary cap era, is trade away draft picks, especially high draft picks. It's just dumb. You need that influx of younger/cheaper talent to keep your more experienced talent around. Do you hear that Mike Tannenbaum?

That's not on Clark. Clark has done an admirable job finding talent in the latter part of the draft. Which is what the scouting staff is paid to do. However, getting rid of high picks has made the Rangers depend on pulling rabbits out of a hat a good deal in the latter rounds.

I understand it brought MSL, I still hate trading draft picks in this era, it drives me nuts.
 
It is a little alarming how poorly the Rangers seem to do in the first round of very good drafts. 2003, 2008, and 2010 they all took major projects in the first round. Jessiman had some unfortunate injuries, but Del Zotto never overcame the same shortcomings that were in his initial scouting reports. Jury is still out on McIlrath, but when you keep missing on stacked drafts, it really starts to bite you in the ass.

Most teams have that draft that sets them up for 5 or 6 years where they get 2 or 3 very good players. The Rangers haven't really had that.
 
People exaggerate the value of draft picks, then whine about it. How many people here are claiming that a #10 pick should be a star? And yet, no star was drafted at #10 since the 1980s. How many people expect our picks in the 18-28 range to become at least second liners? And yet most kids drafted here become minor league busts.

When you have unreasonable expectations that are a magnitude above what history suggests they should be, you will be disappointed.

If the rest of the league is getting 50% busts, while you are scoring only 20% busts, that is called success and not an alarming failure.
 
Last edited:
People complain about our drafts.
People complain about our FA.
People complain about our trades.

I have no idea how such a horrible team was in the Stanley Cup last month.
 
Trxjw said:
It is a little alarming how poorly the Rangers seem to do in the first round of very good drafts. 2003, 2008, and 2010 they all took major projects in the first round. Jessiman had some unfortunate injuries, but Del Zotto never overcame the same shortcomings that were in his initial scouting reports. Jury is still out on McIlrath, but when you keep missing on stacked drafts, it really starts to bite you in the ass.

Most teams have that draft that sets them up for 5 or 6 years where they get 2 or 3 very good players. The Rangers haven't really had that.
Click to expand...

2003 Clark wasn't in his position of power. 2008, Del Zotto was a good pick at the time. HRHR OFD is exactly what this team needed, they got it, he gave the team 3 good years, then he fell off the face of the Earth. I still believe he was rushed. Getting Stepan in the 2nd round more than makes up for DZ failing.

2010 there's nothing to say that hasn't been said.

You have a very good point on teams having that draft where they net a lot of players, and the Rangers have yet to have one. Call me crazy but I think 2013's draft could be that year.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom