First one I thought of was Scott Darling...
You can only be so impressive in the NHL if your name is "Darling".
I've never understood the Grant Fuhr-90s' thing, either. When Fuhr came back from his drug-related League suspension, he was back in the saddle with Edmonton in the '91 playoffs and was excellent (against Calgary). It didn't appear like he had lost anything.
I'm not clear on how good/bad he was in Toronto. In Buffalo, the stats suggest he was pretty good in his first 1/2-season there, but in 1993-94 he wasn't, and Hasek rose up to be best goalie in the League. The gaping difference between Fuhr's stats that season and Hasek's is enormous.
With L.A., from what little I recall (and the stats back it up), he was a train-wreck.
He was barely in the League at that point, and then because of Janet Gretzky talking to Mike Keenan, he goes to St. Louis and has a big career turnaround.
I saw the Fuhr movie, but I haven't read his book. Maybe he goes into that period in detail there, I dunno.