GDT: [Game #61] Dallas Stars vs. New Jersey Devils – 7.00 PM CT (ESPN+)

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
Yeah that's definitely an icing. They really thought that because Harley couldn't knock it out of mid-air that it shouldn't be icing
Yeah, in beer leagues it would be waved off because refs like waving off icings. In the NHL, they don’t count an attempt to play a puck. You either touch it or your don’t.
 
"If they're upset uhh, that's their problem." :Do_O:naughty:

1741146553423.png
 
I swear it said had a higher point total than last year. not pacing. Assumed it was edited in
I edited to make it clearer but the message was the same. Not that it matters. :laugh:

I have a bad habit of editing my messages slightly right after posting them (as I'm doing with this one right now)

(3 edits...)
 
  • Like
Reactions: M88K
Sitting in the stands, I had a bad feeling about the game after 2. NJ was playing pretty well and the Stars never make it easy on themselves, although it looked like they were going to after the 5 on 3 goal.

But, as the song goes, when you're hot, you're hot!
 
Yeah that's definitely an icing. They really thought that because Harley couldn't knock it out of mid-air that it shouldn't be icing
I talked with an NHL linesman years ago. He said that an inability to knock a puck out of the air by many players had no effect on icing because not every player has that skill. He was referring to Derian Hatcher, IIRC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LT
I talked with an NHL linesman years ago. He said that an inability to knock a puck out of the air by many players had no effect on icing because not every player has that skill. He was referring to Derian Hatcher, IIRC.

I rarely see icings get called off unless the player just stops skating. Even if it's on the ice and it just goes through their skates, it gets called most of the time. The point is the puck was cleared too far, not that the defenseman didn't catch it.

The one thing that I see that doesn't follow the rulebook (unless maybe this changed, recently) is missed passes aren't supposed to be icings. That used to get Klingberg in so much trouble, he was off the mark on stretch passes a lot. But I don't have much of a problem with the way it's currently called.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad