If you want to futz with the powerplay, I wouldn't put Anderson on it - the 1 - 3 - 1 has no pure net front role. The Foligno spot and the Gagner spot involve both playmaking and net front play.
Our best guy for the rotor position would be Hartnell - I'd like him to replace Gagner there on the first unit. Hartnell is so underrated - he doesn't miss many opportunities. The guy has excellent vision and passing, a great shot, and when there's a loose puck after a block you want his strength there to tie up sticks and keep the play alive. He's second on the team in 5 on 5 scoring - yet for some reason gets short-shrift on PP, all despite excellent career PP play. Normally you'd think PP immediately for a slow but skilled vet.
Our second unit was looking best when they stuck with the 1 - 3 - 1, Murray high and Jones on the side. I know Dubi and Jenner have been amazing lately but I still don't think they are right for the powerplay.
Murray
Jones - Gagner - Karlsson
Saad