You can go even deeper than the Draft. He needs to go...
Free Agency ---He gets an F and it isn't even debateable.... Backes Belesky and now Lindholm players who's he's over payed for and then had to deal future first to shed the salaries, with the exception of Lindholm but its early.
Trade Market ;... Although He has made some nice deadline acquisitions, He's added no one who's made a long term impact. I guess you can make an argument for Coyle.
That's, A decade of Drafting, Trades and Free Agency. His biggest win by far is McAvoy, then Swayman /Jake but thats it in ten years then it drops off the cliff
He inherited a team with 4 possible HOFers on it in Bergy, Chara, Marchand and Pasta. He also had the likes of Krejci, Lucic, Hamilton, Krug and Tuukka. He's added McAvoy ... in a Decade...WTF?!?!