They got 1 more 5v5 shot than us, but we got significantly better chances, and it shows in the advanced stats;
at 5v5
21-18 in scoring chances
14-5 in High danger chances
2.15 to 1.13 in xGF
All strength we did outshoot then 27-24
25-22 in scoring chances
16-5 in High danger chances
3.05 to 1.23 in xGF
we definitely smothered them, it was the NYI's 3rd worst 5v5 xGF performance of the season, and worst at all year in all situations.
What we didn't do is pepper them with chances, but we still had more all strength xGF (3.05) than the NYI allow on average (2.75)