GDT: Game 38: New York Rangers @ Montreal Canadiens, 7pm, MSG2

[eco's bones]

Just watched Thursday's highlights. They need to change something with that kicking motion rule, there is no way in hell Kreider's goal should've counted.

They are so inconsistent, it really is a joke

Looking at the replay you can see the puck bouncing around in the crease area and Alex Vlasic trying to stick it out of the crease and he gets a piece of it and then right after it goes off Kreider's skates. That to me was the key to why the goal counted---it happening so fast that the refs thought that it going in wasn't so much because Chris decided to kick it in but because the Blackhawk defender put it into his skates.

 

[Hire Sather]

Looking at the replay you can see the puck bouncing around in the crease area and Alex Vlasic trying to stick it out of the crease and he gets a piece of it and then right after it goes off Kreider's skates. That to me was the key to why the goal counted---it happening so fast that the refs thought that it going in wasn't so much because Chris decided to kick it in but because the Blackhawk defender put it into his skates.

Shouldn't really matter, should it? Kreider's intention was to kick (or redirect, whatever. That is the issue, both are the same to me) the puck in. Shouldn't count.

 

[Fitzy]

The way the rule is being interpreted now you pretty much have to goose-step the puck into the net for it to be disallowed

 

[Breaded Fox]

Saturday nights in Montreal suck.

Get out of the first period

One of my favorite games of the last decade and a favorite NYR pic, are from a Saturday night in Montreal...

 

[eco's bones]

Shouldn't really matter, should it? Kreider's intention was to kick (or redirect, whatever. That is the issue, both are the same to me) the puck in. Shouldn't count.

FWIW I'm just giving you a reason why it did count. Whether a goal like that should count is another thing and these calls aren't always consistent. Cuylle's lost two goals this year...one deflecting in off his skate as he was setting up in the slot that was ruled kicked in which was more of a leap as a kicked in goal than this one and IMO should have counted. The other he lost because the ref said he meant to blow the whistle when he hardly would have had time between shot and it crossing the goal line. That should have counted too. I think Cuylle pointing down to the puck crossing the line irritated the refs enough where they decided to kill it. Again inconsistency plays a part in a lot of their decision making so when something goes your way best to take it and not complain.

 

[Rongomania]

Expecting a beatdown. Less go.

 

[KevinFinnerty]

I don't know why I love playing against the Habs. ever since I was a kid the games had a more important feel to them for some reason and they're not even our rivals or anything like that. anyway LGR

 

[hardnosed]

Shouldn't really matter, should it? Kreider's intention was to kick (or redirect, whatever. That is the issue, both are the same to me) the puck in. Shouldn't count.

The rule does not consider kicking and redirecting to be the same thing. One is a goal and one is not a goal.

 

[Hire Sather]

The rule does not consider kicking and redirecting to be the same thing. One is a goal and one is not a goal.

Right. Which IMO is the biggest problem with the rule. They should both be no goal.

 

[mxyxptlk]

I don't know why I love playing against the Habs. ever since I was a kid the games had a more important feel to them for some reason and they're not even our rivals or anything like that. anyway LGR

I think it stems from the fact that they were always the NHL "measuring stick". I loved watching these games more than against any other O6 team because they showed how the game should be played without the cheap stuff and physical bullying. Hockey is a graceful and beautiful game at it's core.

 

[Boris Zubov]

I don't know why I love playing against the Habs. ever since I was a kid the games had a more important feel to them for some reason and they're not even our rivals or anything like that. anyway LGR

Playing in Montreal was agony before the Mark Messier trade. His first game as a Ranger was on a Saturday night & the Rangers hadn't in won in the Forum in something like 7 or 8 years. Rangers tied the game at 1 in the 3rd period & then won it in OT. I'm unsure if Messier had the winner, but the Habs dominance over us playing up there has been pretty much lifted ever since. I think we're 3-0 in playoff series against them.

 

[will1066]

Right. Which IMO is the biggest problem with the rule. They should both be no goal.

 

[hardnosed]

Right. Which IMO is the biggest problem with the rule. They should both be no goal.

Certainly would make it easier on the refs

 

[Shesterkybomb]

Please beat the Habs...too many of these clowns in my area lol

 

[Clark Kellogg]

 

[will1066]

Vesey looks younger than Othmann

 

[Leonardo87]

This thread needs something…

No that’s not it, it needs more Kreider…

 

[redwhiteandblue]

It's only been one game, but I'm much happier OT is up here getting his first meaningful NHL action, with a chance to earn more ice time, rather than feeding Kane 20 minutes a game.

Looking forward to watching this one.

 

[will1066]

This thread needs something…

View attachment 797402

No that’s not it, it needs more Kreider…


View attachment 797403

"Why are you so sweaty?"

"I was watching Cops."

 

[Shesterkybomb]

It's only been one game, but I'm much happier OT is up here getting his first meaningful NHL action, with a chance to earn more ice time, rather than feeding Kane 20 minutes a game.

Looking forward to watching this one.

I just wish they'd pair him with Cuylle, and eventually Trochek, talk about a pesky annoying good skating, skilled line to play against. For now id like to see what they'd do with Brodzinski.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

HUGE game from Laf, iI'm predicting 3 points in his home town(ish).

Lots of friends and family will be there.

 

[JohnBlutarski]

I have returned to give away 2 tickets to tonights showdown.
as it so happens, Air Canada is complete trash and our flight has been cancelled and we are unable to go. I always wanted to see a game at Bell and Air Canada has ruined the dream. Sad i know. Ol Bluto can't catch a break. Play me a song on the worlds smallest violin.
If you, or someone you know is a Rangers fan in Montreal, slide into my DMs. Ill need proof of the fandom. Currently putting them up on ticketmaster as well.
These are not to be resold.
Hfboard moderators and scabs fans need not apply.

 

[KOVALEV022473]

Have to win these games.

I’ll say it again, brutal travel schedule coming up

I don’t know if it can get worse than what we had at the beginning of the season.

 

[mxyxptlk]

I have returned to give away 2 tickets to tonights showdown.
as it so happens, Air Canada is complete trash and our flight has been cancelled and we are unable to go. I always wanted to see a game at Bell and Air Canada has ruined the dream. Sad i know. Ol Bluto can't catch a break. Play me a song on the worlds smallest violin.
If you, or someone you know is a Rangers fan in Montreal, slide into my DMs. Ill need proof of the fandom. Currently putting them up on ticketmaster as well.
These are not to be resold.
Hfboard moderators and scabs fans need not apply.

I guess "Air Cautious" is now "Air Carnage" in your book.

 

[JohnBlutarski]

I guess "Air Cautious" is now "Air Carnage" in your book.

Gonna call them air trudeau.