I still think LaBarbera gets the nod next game though,
I think so too.
Thing is, Labarbera hasn't been too bad this season by his standards. I think everyone would agree the team defense is not where it should be. Far too many good chances are being allowed. And especially early in the season there were a TON of gaffs in the neutral and defensive zones.
Despite all that Labarbera's save % is actually higher than last season. So looking at the team stat side Jason's GAA is .2 higher. For comparison Smith's is .62 higher. Yeah it's a small sample size, but Labarbera has fared better with the weaker defense in front of him.
With how bad Smith has been it's not like we are losing anything.