Toggle sidebar

Gabriel Vilardi or Brandon Hagel?

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates

Who's better?

  • Vilardi

    Votes: 20 28.6%

  • Hagel

    Votes: 49 70.0%

  • Even

    Votes: 1 1.4%
  • Total voters
    70
Hagel. Better track record and bigger sample size. Also locked in at 6.5 mil for a ppg player or better is insane value. Valiardi needs a new contract and will likely be atleast 6.5 mil per or a bit more.

Chevy did well getting valiardi in the dubois trade, chevy is an amazing gm and the jets are lucky to have him. He has had to navigate through a lot of tough situations over the years, laine, wheeler, buf, trouba, dubois…add in Maurice wanting out, it’s like turning on beagm and putting it on insane mode!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Connor McConnor
centipede2233 said:
Hagel. Better track record and bigger sample size. Also locked in at 6.5 mil for a ppg player or better is insane value. Valiardi needs a new contract and will likely be atleast 6.5 mil per or a bit more.
Click to expand...
Hagel is 26 and has never put up a PPG season?

He's having a great year, but let's not count chickens just yet.
 
Hagel is a year older. If you compare Vilardi's most recent 3 years to Hagel at the same age, Vilardi is clearly better offensively, 0.76 PPG to 0.68 PPG.

I don't think either is going to be a Selke candidate. I wonder what it is that is making people say it isn't close. Hagel's current year I suppose?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frolov 6'3
cneely said:
Hagel is 26 and has never put up a PPG season?

He's having a great year, but let's not count chickens just yet.
Click to expand...
He had 79 pts in 81 gp last year, close enough?

cneely said:
Hagel is a year older. If you compare Vilardi's most recent 3 years to Hagel at the same age, Vilardi is clearly better offensively, 0.76 PPG to 0.68 PPG.

I don't think either is going to be a Selke candidate. I wonder what it is that is making people say it isn't close. Hagel's current year I suppose?
Click to expand...
Current year, and the fact he got named to team canada
 
cneely said:
Hagel is a year older. If you compare Vilardi's most recent 3 years to Hagel at the same age, Vilardi is clearly better offensively, 0.76 PPG to 0.68 PPG.

I don't think either is going to be a Selke candidate. I wonder what it is that is making people say it isn't close. Hagel's current year I suppose?
Click to expand...
Ignorance, homerism etc.
 
cneely said:
Hagel is a year older. If you compare Vilardi's most recent 3 years to Hagel at the same age, Vilardi is clearly better offensively, 0.76 PPG to 0.68 PPG.

I don't think either is going to be a Selke candidate. I wonder what it is that is making people say it isn't close. Hagel's current year I suppose?
Click to expand...
Hagel literally is a Selke candidate based on most advanced metrics. Only thing that will hold him back is being a winger.
 
The Macho King said:
Hagel literally is a Selke candidate based on most advanced metrics. Only thing that will hold him back is being a winger.
Click to expand...
His Corsi and Fenwick are almost identical to Vilardi. 56% vs 54%.

There isn't much separating these players. The knock on Vilardi has been his inability to stay healthy and he's a year younger. If he can stay healthy, I expect he closes any gap there is.
 
cneely said:
His Corsi and Fenwick are almost identical to Vilardi. 56% vs 54%.

There isn't much separating these players. The knock on Vilardi has been his inability to stay healthy and he's a year younger. If he can stay healthy, I expect he closes any gap there is.
Click to expand...
We looking at Corsi? What year is it?
 
cneely said:
79 in 82 actually. And no, it's not PPG.

Don't kind yourself. There is one reason he was named to Team Canada.
Click to expand...

Yes because he's 9th overall in the NHL in even strength production since last season. Behind only McDavid and Mackinnon on Canada. I tried to find Vilardi on that list but gave up after 4 pages.

Meanwhile Vilardi's claim to fame is he plays with Connor/Scheifele . Tried to compare their PK minutes too only to realize Vilardis coach doesn't trust him enough to do so.
 
Last edited:
Hagel but Vilardi has such a unique skill set and it’s amazing to watch him in front of the net on the PP
 
Hagel is a selke caliber forward, you can tell who isn't familiar with him as a player. He is one of the better wingers in the game.
 
Hagel is the Bolts' second best player. I can't say I've watched Vilardi play much, but he would have to be at least as good as Brayden Point for this to even be a question.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom