kb
Registered User
- Aug 28, 2009
- 15,313
- 21,869
Better than Vasilevsky, obviouslyHow did he do in the playoffs
Better than Vasilevsky, obviouslyHow did he do in the playoffs
So he’s either on ltir or he’s a cup winning goalie. I don’t see the downside and I doubt Kyle did either and regardless of the GM this was initiated by the player.Come on man, even you have admit that putting Murray a very poor decisions to acquire in the first place on season long LTIR and off the team is the absolute best outcome for the Leafs.
Most knowledgeable people knew it was a REAL bad idea of acquiring an off-injured and unreliable Murray in the first place, so having him serve out the 2nd year on Robidas Island is a better than expected outcome, then even having Murray play 1 game them miss a month, then play another few games and they out indefinitely again, constantly on and off IR all season and unavailable and unreliable.
View attachment 731672
Now Lou Lam's drafted and developed boy & potential goalie of the future Joseph Woll has a clear path to NHL duty, after Murray has been iced and out of the picture long-term.
Leafs get to move on from an ugly inherited mistake without like the last GM using 1st round draft pick capital on Marleau or his own UFA signing blunder Mrazek.
quite the backpedaling and mixed with a decent serving of copium. Looks good on youAll I said was that a player couldn't be put on LTIR unless they were actually hurt.
I said a team can't just "decide" to LTIR a player because it involves multiple medical professionals examining the player and determining that they are unable to play. In the case of LTIR in the off-season, it requires the team doctor to determine that the player will not be medically able to be at training camp and they need to be injured for at least the first ten games of the season. Beyond that, if they want to have him on LTIR deeper into the season, a doctor appointed by the league needs to verify and you also get into insurance and that requires yet another medical professional to agree with the findings.
At no point did I say it wasn't a possibility, you're just making that up. What I said wasn't possible was the Leafs simply deciding to do that without medical evidence of it and Matt Murray being on the same page.
If you want to take shots at me, it's helpful to have a clue what you're talking about.
He would literally be killing his career if he did that. No GM would sign him for anything more than 1M at most because they would never be able to trust him. This is a deal between Tree and Murray...plain and simply if they bought out Murray he would lose a lot of money and makes more sitting. He agreed to this deal because he is always banged up. Should he start to say he isn't anymore...then no GM would want him pulling a stunt like that on them.I actually don't believe much that is said publicly.
We all know that's propaganda.
And who is to say Murray doesn't show up in November saying, "Hey I feel great. When can I start?"
Or maybe he talks to Stone's doctor and gets clearance after the Cap is lifted?
Was there any doubt the Leafs would be Cap compliant come start of season?
Did people actually think they wouldn't be?
Good point……..you win this one. LolBetter than Vasilevsky, obviously
He would literally be killing his career if he did that. No GM would sign him for anything more than 1M at most because they would never be able to trust him. This is a deal between Tree and Murray...plain and simply if they bought out Murray he would lose a lot of money and makes more sitting. He agreed to this deal because he is always banged up. Should he start to say he isn't anymore...then no GM would want him pulling a stunt like that on them.
It is mind boggling for you, but it isn't mind boggling at all for many others. We are aware that if a player is injured for a long term they can be put on reserve. That is what LTIR is for. In fact, it is an acronym for Long Term Injured Reserve.It's mind boggling that there are actually people trying to justify Murray being placed on LTIR as anything other than cap circumvention.
They point to his history of concussions as validation. As if the Leafs are concerned about whether a player's brain gets scrambled. Remember, this was the same team that played Kase fifty games.
Despite having worse history of concussions.
The Leafs are making a rather large bet on their young goaltenders. With Murray on LTIR for the year there is no safety net. Samsonov and Woll have to step up and plough.
The team can't afford to bring anyone else in now.
Yeah there is obviously a lot that goes into it behind the scenes beyond the Leafs just deciding to do it without the player being involved, despite what posters on this site want to believe. Same kind of Leafs fans here that wanted us to just throw Tavares on LTIR until the playoffs as if they could do it without him being hurt.Doesn’t a Dr etc need to sign off on LTIRs???? Media make it sound like the two parties need to agree sounding like it’s nothing lol. I don’t get this whole LTIR thing and insurance etc
Why can't both things be true at the same time?It's mind boggling that there are actually people trying to justify Murray being placed on LTIR as anything other than cap circumvention.
They point to his history of concussions as validation. As if the Leafs are concerned about whether a player's brain gets scrambled. Remember, this was the same team that played Kase fifty games.
Despite having worse history of concussions.
The Leafs are making a rather large bet on their young goaltenders. With Murray on LTIR for the year there is no safety net. Samsonov and Woll have to step up and plough.
The team can't afford to bring anyone else in now.
It's mind boggling that there are actually people trying to justify Murray being placed on LTIR as anything other than cap circumvention.
They point to his history of concussions as validation. As if the Leafs are concerned about whether a player's brain gets scrambled. Remember, this was the same team that played Kase fifty games.
Despite having worse history of concussions.
The Leafs are making a rather large bet on their young goaltenders. With Murray on LTIR for the year there is no safety net. Samsonov and Woll have to step up and plough.
The team can't afford to bring anyone else in now.
A team has to provide proof to the NHL.Doesn’t a Dr etc need to sign off on LTIRs???? Media make it sound like the two parties need to agree sounding like it’s nothing lol. I don’t get this whole LTIR thing and insurance etc
Why can't both things be true at the same time?
Toronto needs the cap relief
And
Murray has a litany of injuries that would make Evel Knievel look bad.
I'll give you some history.
Toronto
9 playoff games head injury
26 games missed due to head injury, abductor, and ankle.
Last year in Ottawa
Missed 36 games with neck, illness, Covid-19, upper body
Last year playing for PIT
14 games missed due to concussion, upper body, lower body,
2nd last year in PIT
Missed 9 games due to concussion
Etc.
I could go on, but it would take hours to list it all.
Doesn’t a Dr etc need to sign off on LTIRs???? Media make it sound like the two parties need to agree sounding like it’s nothing lol. I don’t get this whole LTIR thing and insurance etc
people make jokes, not understanding the situation or how these things work. The team and the player have to agree to this and then it gets filed with the league. There is a good chance that Murray initiated this to take time to get healthy to try and continue his NHL career and get another contract instead of being forced to retire.All I said was that a player couldn't be put on LTIR unless they were actually hurt.
I said a team can't just "decide" to LTIR a player because it involves multiple medical professionals examining the player and determining that they are unable to play. In the case of LTIR in the off-season, it requires the team doctor to determine that the player will not be medically able to be at training camp and they need to be injured for at least the first ten games of the season. Beyond that, if they want to have him on LTIR deeper into the season, a doctor appointed by the league needs to verify and you also get into insurance and that requires yet another medical professional to agree with the findings.
At no point did I say it wasn't a possibility, you're just making that up. What I said wasn't possible was the Leafs simply deciding to do that without medical evidence of it and Matt Murray being on the same page.
people make jokes, not understanding the situation or how these things work. The team and the player have to agree to this and then it gets filed with the league. There is a good chance that Murray initiated this to take time to get healthy to try and continue his NHL career and get another contract instead of being forced to retire.
Pretty sure that’s what ended both Lupul and Jared Cowans careers for good. They didn’t want to play along with Lou’s plan to LTIR them for 1 year. Basically forced to retire after
The funniest part is that Lupul even later admitted how broken down he was, and that he just struggled coming to terms with it.The worst part is that the doctors that deemed them too unhealthy to play and every European league in the world were in on it. The alternative would be believing that Lupul’s ego may have caused him to overestimate his game readiness which we both know is impossible.
The funniest part is that Lupul even later admitted how broken down he was, and that he just struggled coming to terms with it.
And Robidas went pretty in detail about his injury history and what a mess his body was and how he struggled with just daily tasks by the time he finished.
And yet the myths persist.
Same with the “but he was cleared to play in the playoffs” bit as if Bergeron wasn’t cleared to play with a punctured lung and Lidstrom wasn’t cleared to play with a ruptured testicle.