You guys would pass on Gibson?
I mean definitely not my first choice. But he's been on shit teams for several years, I don't think his stats are the best representation of his ability.
Granted, the last time he had good stats with a full starter workload was when he was 25.
Entirely possible he has declined in ability but you can really only know that by watching him over the years. Stat watching with goalies is probably the least reliable thing you can do, especially if they play on garbage teams.