Player Discussion Fire Dustin Schwartz

[KeithIsActuallyBad]

What you're saying is basically quit on the season if they don't fire the goalie coach. It isn't gonna happen.

Trading for a goalie is at least a possibility and the bar for being better than 72nd worst in the league for GSAA is very low.

Again, basically every goalie has turned to mush under Schwartz. Why is the next one any different? Firing him at least allows you the opportunity to actually conduct a search wider than "Were they the goalie coach for the Oil Kings?"

If nothing else it sends a message to the rest of the team and staff that failure will not be tolerated.

 

[Soundwave]

Again, basically every goalie has turned to mush under Schwartz. Why is the next one any different? Firing him at least allows you the opportunity to actually conduct a search wider than "Were they the goalie coach for the Oil Kings?"

If nothing else it sends a message to the rest of the team and staff that failure will not be tolerated.

Because not every goalie here has fizzled within 1 year.

Talbot had multiple good years, so did Smith.

Seeing as how we have a window of like a few years, who really gives as shit about 2-3 years from now, we'll worry about that when we get there. We need to maximize the immediate window.

 

[KeithIsActuallyBad]

Because not every goalie here has fizzled within 1 year.

Talbot had multiple good years, so did Smith.

Seeing as how we have a window of like a few years, who really gives as shit about 2-3 years from now, we'll worry about that when we get there. We need to maximize the immediate window.

Smith blatantly IGNORED Schwartz. What does that tell you?

And again as I've stated, Talbot got progressively worse every year. His final year here was abysmal.

I don't even understand why Talbot is part of this conversation. He's not coming here, period.

 

[Soundwave]

Smith blatantly IGNORED Schwartz. What does that tell you?

And again as I've stated, Talbot got progressively worse every year. His final year here was abysmal.

I don't even understand why Talbot is part of this conversation. He's not coming here, period.

It tells me he sucks, but Talbot is old now too, what exactly does he need to listen to Schwartz for?

Talbot didn't get progressively worse either, his first year here was .917, then it went up to .919 and higher in the playoffs to .924.

Why do people think 16-17 was Talbot's first year here? It wasn't, we got him the day after we drafted McDavid, that's 2015, not 2016.

 

[KeithIsActuallyBad]

It tells me he sucks, but Talbot is old now too, what exactly does he need to listen to Schwartz for?

Talbot didn't get progressively worse either, his first year here was .917, then it went up to .919 and higher in the playoffs to .924.

Why do people think 16-17 was Talbot's first year here? It wasn't, we got him the day after we drafted McDavid, that's 2015, not 2016.

Go check Talbot's stats the last two playoffs. And spare me the "McDavid/Draisatl" nonsense when Silovs, Oettinger and Bobrovsky seemed to do just fine. His last "good" playoffs was in 2021 and even then the Stars beat him like a rented mule before they became the powerhouse they are today.

 

[CanadasTeam99]

Smith blatantly IGNORED Schwartz. What does that tell you?

And again as I've stated, Talbot got progressively worse every year. His final year here was abysmal.

I don't even understand why Talbot is part of this conversation. He's not coming here, period.

He did not ignore him. I have even asked Gregor in person. THis was a different type of coach. More about non goalie mechanics. He has said the same on Twitter as well.

 

[KeithIsActuallyBad]

He did not ignore him. I have even asked Gregor in person. THis was a different type of coach. More about non goalie mechanics. He has said the same on Twitter as well.

Gregor is an ardent Schwartz defender. I asked him on Twitter a few years ago why he hasn't been canned and he spoke to me like I suggested nuking a country.

 

[McDNicks17]

He did not ignore him. I have even asked Gregor in person. THis was a different type of coach. More about non goalie mechanics. He has said the same on Twitter as well.

Sounds like Gregor has no idea what he's talking about.

Francillia's coaching is basically all goaltending mechanics. He pretty much rebuilt Smith to stop leaning, falling and swimming around in the crease.

 

[bobbythebrain]

So how does a goalie coach work exactly?

In Van the new guy has made Silovs bad but Lankinen good?

Or how about Wash? Lilgren was a beast last year but now his goalie coach decided to sabotage him and made Thompson goid instead?

Kinda weird how a goalie coach can be effective and ineffective simultaneously. No?

 

[Soundwave]

Go check Talbot's stats the last two playoffs. And spare me the "McDavid/Draisatl" nonsense when Silovs, Oettinger and Bobrovsky seemed to do just fine. His last "good" playoffs was in 2021 and even then the Stars beat him like a rented mule before they became the powerhouse they are today.

He only played 1 game in the 2022 playoffs so that's virtually irrelevant.

In our series, Connor and Leon on top of shredding most goalies (go ask Oeteniger, Markstrom, even Bobrovsky went from a Conn Smythe lock at game 3 to having his numbers crater the next 3 games) is tough for any goalie but Connor and Leon also know Cam inside/out. That's a very specific kind of situation that isn't going to apply when Talbot plays anyone else.

No one else has a McDavid or Draisaitl except us who know Talbot inside/out because they played 4 years together.

 

[KeithIsActuallyBad]

So how does a goalie coach work exactly?

In Van the new guy has made Silovs bad but Lankinen good?

Or how about Wash? Lilgren was a beast last year but now his goalie coach decided to sabotage him and made Thompson goid instead?

Kinda weird how a goalie coach can be effective and ineffective simultaneously. No?

Do those teams hire goalie coaches from their local WHL team?

He only played 1 game in the 2022 playoffs so that's virtually irrelevant.

In our series, Connor and Leon on top of shredding most goalies (go ask Oeteniger, Markstrom, even Bobrovsky went from a Conn Smythe lock at game 3 to having his numbers crater the next 3 games) is tough for any goalie but Connor and Leon also know Cam inside/out. That's a very specific kind of situation that isn't going to apply when Talbot plays anyone else.

No one else has a McDavid or Draisaitl except us who know Talbot inside/out because they played 4 years together.

He still sucked at the end of the day. If Skinner put up a >5 GAA in any series you'd tear a strip off him.

 

[Soundwave]

Do those teams hire goalie coaches from their local WHL team?


He still sucked at the end of the day. If Skinner put up a >5 GAA in any series you'd tear a strip off him.

Skinner doesn't have a .915 career in the playoffs, nor did he have a playoffs where he was better than McDavid and Draisaitl like Talbot did, nor is he sitting no.3 in the NHL in save percentage right now.

Skinner is .894 in the playoffs, Talbot even with the series where McDavid/Drai took advantage of him is still .915 ... that's night and day difference. We win the Cup last year with .915.

If Skinner wants to have the same benefit of the doubt, the can go do the same things, until then, no.

Cam Talbot has never (regardless of goaltending coach) had Dan Cloutier-esque numbers through multiple playoff rounds where he was the starter. Skinner did that.

 

[KeithIsActuallyBad]

Skinner doesn't have a .915 career in the playoffs, nor did he have a playoffs where he was better than McDavid and Draisaitl like Talbot did, nor is he sitting no.3 in the NHL in save percentage right now.

Skinner is .894 in the playoffs, Talbot even with the series where McDavid/Drai took advantage of him is still .915 ... that's night and day difference. We win the Cup last year with .915.

If Skinner wants to have the same benefit of the doubt, the can go do the same things, until then, no.

Cam Talbot has never (regardless of goaltending coach) had Dan Cloutier-esque numbers through multiple playoff rounds where he was the starter. Skinner did that.

You're right, he had Cloutier-esque numbers through the first round last year and let his team down. Much better. And his numbers were far, far worse than any other goalie the Oilers faced. He. Sucked. He was worse than David Rittich for Pete's sake.

If Talbot couldn't handle the Oilers do you think he would've fared better against the Stars and Panthers?

 

[Soundwave]

You're right, he had Cloutier-esque numbers through the first round last year and let his team down. Much better. And his numbers were far, far worse than any other goalie the Oilers faced. He. Sucked. He was worse than David Rittich for Pete's sake.

If Talbot couldn't handle the Oilers do you think he would've fared better against the Stars and Panthers?

You really gonna keep arguing this guy:

Currently: 5th best in the NHL for save percentage, no.2 in the NHL for GSAA above Connor Helleybuck

Career .915 save percentage in the playoffs


Is worse than Stuart Skinner

Currently: 46th best in the NHL for save percentage, 72nd worst (out of 74 ranked goalies) in the NHL for GSAA

Career: .894 in the playoffs

?

If that's the hill you want to die on, go right ahead.