Proposal: Fayne , Edmonton 1st and Puljujarvi

[McSuper]

You make this post, without giving any

realistic targets

/trades in your OP and then rip the head off the first person who responds...

Any fan on HF knows Shattenkirk will not sign with Edmonton . There is a thing call common sense . Would you trade a top 4 pick for a player with 1 year left on their contract that you know won't sign with you ? Come on this is not rocket science .

The above highlighted should have answered itself for you . 1 year rental don't get you a top 4 pick plus another 1st and yet you talk of realistic

 

[member 157595]

here are the RHD that I could think of (-25y/o)... how many in there would you think are available at that cost...?

John Klingberg
Tyson Barrie
Dougie Hamilton
Rasmus Ristolainen
Sami Vatanen
Justin Faulk
Aaron Ekblad
Colton Parayko
Ryan Ellis
Seth Jones
Cody Ceci
Matt Dumba
Jacob Trouba
Damon Severson

Thanks for the list. That's certainly a huge range of value, and I'm having a hard time figuring out which defenseman fits best in the 1st, Fayne, Puljujarvi range...some of those guys are simply unavailable while others like Dumba and Severson are a bad return for the Edmonton package.

 

[DJJones]

For that package you would be close to Faulk.

No way either side accepts though

 

[Stuzchuk]

Thanks for the list. That's certainly a huge range of value, and I'm having a hard time figuring out which defenseman fits best in the 1st, Fayne, Puljujarvi range...some of those guys are simply unavailable while others like Dumba and Severson are a bad return for the Edmonton package.

I knew that not all would fit in for that package... but at least it gives an idea of what's out there... but which one are available and at what cost that an entire different story

 

[OilersFanatics505]

He still wants too much money . We need a reasonable cap hit . Mcdavid and Draisaitl will be looking for raises soon enough

Because teams just have those lying around? Give me a break!

 

[Fear the Wushu]

The Devils offer you Taylor Hall for that package. A young bonafide elite winger signed on a great contract.

 

[Sweep*]

Petry++ for Puljujärvi?

 

[snipes]

Petry++ for Puljujärvi?

Nope.

Don't know why OP made this thread. Pulju has a long-term future with the Oilers.

 

[A91]

The Devils offer you Taylor Hall for that package. A young bonafide elite winger signed on a great contract.

A scoring winger is the last of our needs. Need a RHS defenseman, someone like Adam Larsson for example.

 

[Johansen2Foligno]

Ryder, Halak, 2nd

 

[Canada4Gold]

Again my bad . The TML has a Brown and a Green . But you have to agree it was an offer with the intent to start something

Sorry TML fans

Not sure what Greene or Green the Leafs have.

Oh you mean Greening, nvm then. Thought it was obvious the poster was a Kings fan though

 

[Skobel24]

Value wise, that could likely get a discussion going for Brodie. Wouldn't happen realistically though for obvious reasons (division rivals, Calgary won't trade him, ect)

Edit: I know you said RHD. Brodie is LH, but prefers the right side.